Wow. Super scary idea.
I can only imagine it would take a very extreme combination of crazy/stupid/whatever to do something like that. I would hate to think any of us might cross paths with such a person at a horse show or in the checkout line at the Publix in Loxahatchee.
If someone were, in fact, crazy/stupid/whatever enough to do such a thing, wouldn’t it make much more sense to shoot the foot or some other location that seems less likely to cause death? Which was what almost happened to LK, according to the surgeon who testified.
Although maybe if someone were that crazy/stupid/whatever, the logical thought process of wound location might be a bit too much to ask.
I hate to say it, but in the scenario described above, wouldn’t it make more sense to shoot the dog? And claim MB did it? (Once again, poor Rosie.)
All these things make me think it would be much more likely that the first option in the original post could have happened, where there was a struggle and the gun went off during the struggle.