I remember that thread. The photo was of an 8yr old Lillie Keenan on the cover of the Dover Saddlery catalogue. I think it was started by someone who couldn’t ride nearly as well but found it necessary to critique an 8 year old’s equitation. 
5 Likes
I remember that thread all too well.
I wonder how many of those critics have ever represented the US in international competition, much less won the Nations’ Cup at multiple major shows against the best in the world.
8 Likes
and lets ALSO remember the complete VITRIOL that came out on this very forum, when she was on the cover of Dover (I think it was Dover?)
Some things never change…
To answer the question, I believe Rico Suave is 250/ year, for just one example.
ETA: I see now I am late to the party. (And yes! My memory isn’t totally sh!t yet)
2 Likes
Does anyone have a link to the OG photo? To be fair to the aghast posters, maybe it wasn’t terribly flattering, even though she was always a terrific rider?
I did a Google, and found some photos of her from 2007 riding ponies:
https://www.chronofhorse.com/article/keenan-continues-her-winning-streak-pony-finals/
I don’t have a photo, but if I recall correctly, it was a lovely photo of the pony but the child, who was eight years old at the time, was pinching with her knee and her lower leg was back of her body, so as a result her hip angle was quite closed.
As children (and adults) may do, especially when they are maturing and figuring out their bodies.
Naturally this was everything that was wrong with the sport all in one picture of a child.
If Lillie Keenan’s development as a rider is everything wrong with the sport, I’m not sure we want to be right!
On a totally different note, I am gobsmacked (and I probably shouldn’t be) that for low-mid six figures you could lease a winning division pony for a few months or alternatively you could buy Cooley Quicksilver.
I’ll grant you that I could probably ride one of the ponies but I doubt I’m good enough to ride the horse!
13 Likes
I read the original thread and I’m pretty sure it’s this one. It was on a dover catalog cover but I couldn’t find the actual catalog. However, based off descriptions, I think this is it.
7 Likes
Stunning picture - then and now.
9 Likes
Wow, thanks for digging that up! I agree it’s a beautiful photo.
I do think 20+ years ago there was more of an emphasis in the hunter world on jamming your heels down in a more extreme way, but that has been talked about in many other threads!
1 Like
Easily $100,000, minimum. I work in commercial insurance. Somehow became the brokerage’s default “farm insurance” account manager – aka “give it to TheDBYC, she probably knows what she’s looking at”.
My colleagues are continually floored when I attempt to describe the factors contributing to the insurable value of a lot of show hunter pony:
“BUT, BUT, IT’S AN ANIMAL!!! MY HOUSE COST LESS THAN THAT!”
Yes, I know. 
Eta: Briefly breathed the same air as Mr Magoo at Upperville a few years back. It felt like what seeing Timothee Chalomet must be like . DD18 always frames it as: “Mr. Magoo got a new kid this season.”
13 Likes
I recall a bay pony and pink bows. But the basic position was the same. Darling pony jumping well, child showing age-appropriate skills. Pass me my smelling salts and a strand of pearls to clutch.
3 Likes
I re-read that old thread.
I could do more good with Aunt Esther’s purse. My pearls are in no danger 
2 Likes
That’s not the photo, it was a bay pony, a 3/4 shot, and LK was MUCH younger
7 Likes
Ohhh ok. I wasn’t actually around for the thread itself. I just saw someone in the thread say it was a “tdf gray pony”
Definitely not the same picture. But the picture on the catalog was quite cute.
And more to the point, it was a young child who did not post the picture herself or ask a bunch of random strangers on the internet for a critique of any kind.
4 Likes
I’m actually 99% sure that the photo was on Aspen Spring, who was a small grey pony who lived to be approximately 1000 years old. Lillie is wearing an olive green/tan-ish jacket. It was a nearly head-on shot.
However, I am struggling very hard to find the photo. It is not the one that was posted above - I don’t think that’s even Lillie riding.
12 Likes
My searches keep showing me a photo of her on Beau Rivage and that is only DEEPENING MY RESOLVE TO FIND IT because I CAN PICTURE IT IN MY HEAD
7 Likes
I FOUND A LINK TO THE PHOTO IN QUESTION but it doesn’t work so I’m gonna trawl through some internet archive sites to see if I can recover it.
I’m a woman on a mission now.
7 Likes
I GOT IT
I GOT ITTTTTTTTTTTTTTT
51 Likes
Impressive search skills!!!
3 Likes
Impressive! What did you search to find it? I tried, but I’m better at googling construction stuff obviously, but a good thing since I work in the industry.
2 Likes
