Look, if I were not staring down the barrel of my 60th year on the planet, I probably would still have a slim calf. But I don’t. FAR from it! (In breeches, measuring widest part in a sitting position like the diagrams always show, I measure 16" around!) I also don’t have a regular sized foot for my height (7 DD), nor a regular length of leg from the floor to the back of my knee. (19"). So I have a short, fat foot, an “ample” calf girth, and a super tall leg. But I’m not THAT large. My calf is - call me Popeye. Yes, I’m overweight, mostly my middle. But what I’ve been noticing is that even XW calf in just about every decent boot I looked at measures 15" around if I am to get anywhere near my foot size.
Obviously, I need custom boots. Off the rack boots just aren’t going to work. I’ve made my current (bought used) semi-custom Petries work pretty well for a while and they are currently getting resoled so I can limp them along a bit longer until I can save up for full custom. But like all non-custom boots I’ve tried, I have to buy a 1/2 size bigger than I need in the foot so I can get the width. I sometimes have purchase several sizes too big to get the height, etc. Then I have to have a zipper and/or gussets put in to add to the width.
It seems to me that the boot manufacturers are missing a big opportunity here. My legs may be put together oddly, but I can’t be the only one. Imagine if more of the high end boot makers had a facility whereby they could make a semi custom by putting one shoe size together with one shaft (height/width) size. Not only would they be able to fit many more people, but they could have a much quicker turnaround time. My shoe size would be 7.5 or 8 (to get the width) and shaft would be what they would normally use for a men’s size 11 or 12.
I remember when I had some boots made years ago. The manufacturer came back to the salesperson at the store and asked for the measurements 3 times! They just couldn’t believe such an odd duck was actually walking around. FWIW, I do not seem to appear odd if I walk toward you. Just if I take off my shoe and hike up my pant leg. LOL