Cat won't poop in litter box

My cat is an 8 - 9 year old female orange tabby, fixed, and in a single-cat home. My step sister rescued her as a kitten from a gas station where the owner was planning on drowning them. I didn’t live with her during her kitten years, but when she was 2 or 3, she moved in with myself, and my mother and step father. We had two dogs for about 5 of those years, but they paid her no attention.

She will use the litter box to urinate and maybe one poop, but after that will poop on the floor outside the box. She has been doing this behaviour since day one. She doesn’t like other cats, but she lived with a male cat for a period of 7 months.

She has lived with me for the last 4 years, alone. The litter box is at the basement landing, and its cleaned once a day. I use Tidy Cat litter, and the litter is replaced entirely and the box cleaned with Dawn dish soap. She is fed 1/4 cup of Crave cat food twice a day. She has been on this food for a little over a year, and before that it was Friskies, fed at the same amount.

To be honest, she isn’t the nicest cat in the world - I remember holding her as a kitten, and she was tucked up to my chest, growling. She likes to be near you, but not touching, I can pet her head and neck, but any farther will result in a bite, and I can hold her, but only for about a minute. She has to be burritoed to have her nails clipped, and vet visits require a tech restraining her wearing leather gloves.

Urine crystals have been ruled out, she isn’t constipated, the poop is normal consistency and size, and has no strange odour. She is healthy in every other way. At her age, correcting the behaviour is probably impossible, but does anyone have any suggestions on how to fix the problem?

FWIW…I’ve had house cats for the best part of 15 years…I have 4 now and keep 3 litter boxes in different parts of the house…I have gone to using large clear totes (approx. 18x30x14 deep… give or take) and have gone to wooden pellet animal bedding for litter…I put the new pellets in one end of the tote…leave bare tote flooring then the pellets that have broken down to sawdust in the opposite end. That way the cats can choose how deep the litter is where they poop. One female prefers to “go” on the bare plastic floor and then cover it up. So far…everyone is happy with the set up and we don’t get any “violations”…and cleaning once a day…there is NO SMELL!! I have never found a “Cat Litter”…cheap or expensive that they all liked before!!

That’s an interesting thought, I’ve never thought about changing the type of litter. I’ve used the Tidy Cat litter, and when she lived with my parents, we used a No Name brand. Maybe she doesn’t like the feel of the granules. I haven’t seen wood pellet bedding in pet stores around here, unless you mean the wood pellets you use in horse stalls. I just have a regular open litter box, would you suggest finding something bigger?

I had a male cat(Bucky Kat)for 13 years that would pee no problem in the litter box but would poop on the floor right beside the litter box every 2nd-3rd day. I tried every type and size of litter box finally settling on a large tote, I tried every type of cat litter finally settling on clay. Litter boxes were/are cleaned every day I sprayed the spots with Nature’s Miracle every time I cleaned it up. Bucky had decided that was where he was going to poop so I just let him be and cleaned up after him for 13 years, everyone thought I was crazy but he was my responsibility and I owned up to it. Some cats are just funny that way and no matter what we do they’re just going to keep doing it. I’ve had indoor cats for over 40 years and Bucky was the only one with that problem…so far.

1 Like

I fully believe that some cats are selected for–accidentally–to have litter box problems. People have a cat, it can’t figure out the box, and they dump it outside. It breeds with another cat that was dumped outside for similar reasons, and ta-da, they produce a litter with varying degrees of not wanting to use the box. Some can adapt to normal cat life, and some really cannot.

Absolutely play around with litter, play around with box location and type, play around with anti anxiety meds, try feliway. But this cat might just not be wired to go potty in the box :-/

I’m glad I’m not the only one going through this! Miss Kitty is an odd duck, but I love her, quirks and all. Luckily the litter box is on tiled floor, so the clean up is pretty easy.

@Simkie - She’s been doing this her entire life, so I’m thinking you’re right - she’s just wired this way.

Given the age / history …I would recommend going to Home Depot for (a large plastic square tray) used * for under washing machines … low lip on it …

place the litter box in this tray to one side … sprinkle a little litter (just a little) on the other side directly in the tray … hopefully with a little moving the litter box around in the tray … the cat will urinate in the litter box and deposit his poop next to the litter box but in the tray.

This works for elderly cats or injured cats … easy in and easy out …low lip on tray …large area to use for urinating or pooping or both.

  • if there is an exact spot he poops … a dog
    / puppy pad would also help in clean up if you dislike the washing machine tray idea.

Good Luck !

1 Like

Washer pans are da bomb. Good idea ZuZu.

My boxes are in washer pans because sometimes, my male doesn’t put in much effort to squat and sprays out the hole (litter box entry). It is now rare but it sure saves the carpet/flooring. May work a treat for your guy.

Susan

1 Like

Have you ever tried having 2 litter boxes? Some cats are super picky about what’s in their box and how clean it is. I know that you clean daily, but maybe 2 boxes to choose from would interest her. Especially if she has already pooped in one but you haven’t done your cleaning yet, then the other one has no poop and may be more appealing for her next use.

FWIW I have 2 cats and 2 boxes. One an actual litter box, the other a large plastic tote. They prefer to use whatever box has carbon/unscented litter in it. Anything with a perfume sent is a no! I don’t fancy the fragranced litters either, so no problem for me.

1 Like

Bucky was not doing it accidentally, I saw the absolute proof of that.

He figured out the litter boxes from day one, he preferred to use one of the five I had throughout the house and it was within my sight to see him do this regularly. I do know his mum was either feral or an abandoned cat, I adopted both him and his brother Mo Jo at the same time.Bucky wouldn’t even attempt to enter the litter box on the days he decided he wanted to poop on the floor, sometimes he would go in the litter box to pee and then step out to poop on the floor other times he would just go right up to the litter box and then poop on the floor. It wasn’t every day and he never peed outside of the box.

I also find it odd and it has no real explanation…some cats fastidiously cover up their mess while others don’t always. The ones that do will go behind the ones that don’t and cover it up for them.

I slipped a piece of linoleum under Bucky’s litter box.

Bucky wasn’t an odd duck, he was what we called “mentally challenged or stoooopid”. Whether his lack of grey matter was inherited or caused from an accident after his birth were not sure. We also called him Boy Blunder. :lol:

I didn’t say that this behavior is accidental. I said that we have selected for this behavior accidentally.

Yes, sorry…I realized that after I posted my response.

Like people, animals are all wired differently and much of it depends on genetics and conditioning directly after birth.

Some owners beat themselves up with trying to get to the root of the problem and “fixing” it, when sometimes it doesn’t matter what or how much you do it can’t be fixed.

Rereading your initial post, @BrookdaleBay , one other thing to rule out here would be pain, especially given that she doesn’t like to be touched. Perhaps it’s just hard for her to assume the position on the shifting litter, and easier/more comfortable for her to squat on the solid floor surface. A course of pain meds might be worthwhile dart at the board…

1 Like

[B]* many many threads on this topic …

some cats exhibit this behavior due to ???

pain
an unkept litter box
arthritis
other cats intimidating them [/B]
lacking the litter box brain cell that fires all the way across their little head :winkgrin:
and then there are some cats who just prefer to crap outside the litter box on the floor :lol:

  • we love our cats and just try to accommodate their behaviors :smiley:

ENJOY YOUR WEEKEND CAT LOVERS !!

I get our pellets at an Atwoods (or any "Farm Supply type store) you don’t want “Pellet Stove”, wood pellets, but the horse stall type…they are clean and safe. I don’t know WHY they prefer the bigger tote…but for a few $$$$ you can give it a try…works for our cats…cuts down on the litter “dust” being tracked out on the floor, too.

This is an interesting thought. I never considered pain since she also did this as a young cat, but during the time I’ve had her, she doesn’t jump on high surface. Her food dish in on the counter, and while she makes it 90% of the time, other times she misses the mark and bounces off the counters. When she wants on my bed, she climbs up the mattresses instead of jumping. Jumping down is no problem… that I can see, anyway. Arthritis is a good consideration.

Our cat would miss the box often. I happened to catch him in the act once and found that him being a large cat he really had little room for error.

I thought the box was big until I saw him in it. Could it just be that the way she is positioned and trying to go, it is just missing the mark??

Get a larger litter pan??

I’ve noticed that sometimes cats, given a choice will use one pan for pee and the other for poop. I’ll have to check out washer pans. I use a boot tray under one of ours. We had to start another pan on our lower level because our older kitty wasn’t making it upstairs in time. He is very clean so he found what he thought were suitable alternatives like floor mats but now he has a pan in the living room he uses it faithfully. Having said that, he does over shoot his poop.

I have some litter I love called Feline Fresh. It isn’t widely available here (eg not in Pet Smart) but is made in the US so you might be able to get it (just noticed you are in Ontario - I get it at Big Als in Hamilton, and don’t know where else to get it). It is a pine product but it clumps sort of. My kitty really likes it. It is not as dusty as clay and smells much fresher. I did use stall pellets but was really annoyed at paying twice as much for a tiny bag in the pet store compared to a feed store but don’t have the room in my condo for a huge bag of pellets. If I had a house with a garage that is the way I would have gone.

That’s a good thought, but she’s a small cat and the poop is several feet away from the box. I will try a large box, though, she might just need more room.

1 Like