Chews/bones for dog that swallows everything whole

I am typing very slowly because there are six major puncture wounds in my left middle finger and it’s wrapped in gauze. That’s from trying to remove a 3" piece of turkey chew from my dachshund’s throat as she gasped for air and simultaneously tried to eat every last morsel of it.

Every freaking chew, bone, etc., that I give her, I have to usually pry a piece from her throat/mouth as she tries to inhale large shards. I have tried so many different ones, but this always happens–she’s just so food-driven that she wants to swallow everything whole.

At the same time, she loves them, they’re great for my other dog, and I just want to find something she can chew on that won’t kill her (or make her bite my finger off while she chokes). Any suggestions?

She does have a Kong and a puzzle toy that I give her kibble/small soft treats in. She’s not interested in Nylabones, antlers, anything that is not actually food of some sort.

How about a BIG knuckle bone from the butcher. I boil them to remove meat and grease, but with a Boxer, Boerboel, Great Pyrennes and A Pappillon, my bones have lasted for years. I NEVER buy rawhide anymore. Too much choke risk. Sorry about your hand!!

Hmm, I’ll have to try the knuckle bone… I also avoid rawhide, I know that’s just going to tear off into swallow-able pieces!

Incidentally, I also found my horse’s Himalayan salt brick in chunks in his bucket today. Previously he cracked a tooth eating one of the rock-style ones. Why are all my animals trying to kill themselves?!?

Cuz…THAT’S what animals do to make us crazy and feel wanted!!! I coined a phrase years ago…“Horses…the only business where your inventory eats, sh*ts, and tries to commit suicide”!! But we still love them!!!

Just a warning with knucklebones - scoped one out of a boxer last night. Thankfully no esophogeal damage, but $4800 to the owners.

If your dog is known to swallow things without chewing, I would stay clear of bones period. Frozen treats (ie tin food frozen into larger shapes) will satisfy the gnawing, and dissolve in the esophagus/tummy if she should swallow it whole.

I know many people who feed knucklebones have no issues with them,but I have seen enough get lodged in the distal esophagus to cause major damage, even death :frowning:

1 Like

Any thoughts on antlers? I gave her a deer antler for Christmas, and she seems to enjoy chewing on that and it seems sturdy so far… but I’m not sure if it will start to break down at some point. Really hope not, because that seems to be the best option I’ve found!

[QUOTE=SarahandSam;6739263]
Any thoughts on antlers? I gave her a deer antler for Christmas, and she seems to enjoy chewing on that and it seems sturdy so far… but I’m not sure if it will start to break down at some point. Really hope not, because that seems to be the best option I’ve found![/QUOTE]

I dont like antlers (ever stepped ohn one? ouch!) but have never experienced a dog with an antler fragment stuck anywhere. IMHO better than knucklebones for dogs who like to bypass chewing.

Nylabones. But they can hurt you too if you step on them in the dark of night.

if she’s not that hip to the normal nylabone, try this…throw some chicken broth in a sauce pan. Bring to a boil. Remove from heat and throw the bone in. Let soak for a bit. Usually works like a charm.

Another hint: get a used nylabone from a friend. I kid you not, a well used nylabone seems to get otherwise uninterested dogs very very interested! I could send you one!

1 Like

I swear by Nylabones. We have a hound puppy which, I’ve learned = LOTS of chewing. Our JRT puppy was never a chewer… this guy… anything is fair game.

We got him a Nylabone for Christmas and he hasn’t left it alone.

We also go the Kong stuffed with frozen yogurt or peanut butter route.

1 Like

I “used” to buy Nylabones, but read that they were bad!! Tell me they are not and I’d go back to them. My dogs, especially the Boxer and Boerboel are chewing nuts!! I have two “petrified” cow leg bones. Think rock hard. The two dogs will each grab and end and go at it for an hour before they tire out. I’ve never had them even chip one. Not available in pet stores though!! Only available in old cow pastures!!

The problem with cow femurs (which my dogs love too) is that those bones are actually harder than the tooth enamel and can really wear away at the teeth.

Be careful with knuckle bones. You never ever EVER want to give dogs bones you’ve cooked/boiled. It makes the bone brittle, so when pieces break off and are swallowed they can perforate their stomach or bowels.

Have you tried large frozen bully sticks? Those are digestible and tend to work pretty well. Frozen kongs or other types of frozen treats are good as well. However, if the dog is swallowing a lot of stuff whole, I’d stay away from most hard chews. Too much of a risk for choking or impacting their intestines. Nylabones aren’t digestible, so if swallowed they can cause some serious issues.

[QUOTE=BuddyRoo;6739667]
The problem with cow femurs (which my dogs love too) is that those bones are actually harder than the tooth enamel and can really wear away at the teeth.[/QUOTE]

Thanks for that info.

I’m reading this with interest as I have one too…a JRT that gulps. I have retrieved many a treat or chew from that throat, including a sweet potato chew last night (now banned from the house, like raw hides and bully sticks and chicken chips…I’ve retrieved them all).

She does like antlers ok, for a short time. We took some we had around and boiled them in a little chicken stock to make them more appealing, which worked, and didnt seem to soften them. She loves the half elk antlers that have the marrow still in there, but that only lasts a couple of days and they aren’t cheap!

Even buying the big chews that she can’t possibly gulp doesn’t work as that little terrorist always manages to tear a gulpable piece off.

And don’t get me started on squeakers…!

For those of you with small to medium dogs who love to scare us to death, the best way to go is with * extremely oversized" rawhide bones, but the ones without the knuckes.

I had a Portuguese Serra D’aires when I was a kid who would swallow just about anything she could get into her mouth. That meant plastic, wood, paper, large bones, rocks… you get the picture.

We started giving her the rawhide bones meant for Large dogs and because she couldn’t swallow it hole, we were fine. Oh, but we did take it away as soon as we saw it was getting too small.

My dog Colt (see profile picture) is a 95 lb Dutch Shepherd and is a very heavy/determined chewer and he cannot break any of the antlers I have gotten him in the past year and has only worked one of them down to a size that might be swallowed by a gulper. I have found that unlike bones they do not fracture at the edges and my pet store has a few different types/species (deer, elk, moose) of antlers to pick from so they do not get bored of just one flavor.

I also have to mention that I found an amazingly strong ball for my (determined to destroy all toys) Colt, it looks like it would pop in two seconds but he has had it for two weeks and can bite it as hard as he wants without it popping so far! It is the Petco Bouncing Spiney Ball; http://www.petco.com/product/113911/Petco-Bouncing-Spiney-Ball-Dog-Toy.aspx?CoreCat=OnSiteSearch

We often freak out unnecessarily when we see our dogs gulping down huge chunks of food, but that’s how dogs naturally eat- they swallow large chunks of meat/bone, and then it gets digested. It’s normal for them to swallow huge chunks of food. As long it’s digestible, it will either dissolve in the stomach, or if it doesn’t dissolve, the dog will puke it up later. Usually you only get problems if the dog happens to swallow something that isn’t digestible. One of my dogs once swallowed an entire rabbit, fur, head, and all, and digested it just fine.

So the IMPORTANT thing is not that the dog swallows it, but that what the dog is swallowing is a digestible substance.

Nylabones aren’t safe at all- they aren’t digestible, and the company makes them so they don’t show up on x-rays so when your dog swallows a chunk of them and the gut is blocked by the chunk of plastic your vet won’t be able to see it.

AND NEVER EVER give your dog a smoked or boiled or cooked bone- the heating process renders the bone indigestible and brittle. Those smoked bones they sell in pet stores are dog-killers. They are brittle, thus the dog can break off pieces, which then get swallowed and can’t be digested because they are cooked.

Sometimes you’ll see cow hooves for sale- these don’t appear to be very digestible either, so perhaps best avoided. Rawhide is not very digestible so it’s best avoided.

Antlers are just bone- uncooked bone, thus digestible. Bully sticks, tendons, and tripe chews are digestible. Any uncooked raw bone should be digestible, but the sturdy weight-bearing leg bones of say cows are often so hard that the dog’s teeth might break- the softer joint ends (the knuckles) are safer than the hard shaft (marrow bones and the like). Frozen raw turkey necks make excellent chews for the smaller dogs- fully digestible, and take some chewing.

If you want the dog to spend time chewing rather than swallow it, get something bigger than the dog’s head so there’s no way it’s going down whole.

I’m a big fan of kong toys filled with whatever…I’ve shoved peanut butter in them, dog kibble, carrots, plain rice cake pieces, ice cubes, etc. It’s a great toy for busy bodies.

Good luck and hope your hand is healed soon…oh those little wiener dogs!! Used to hate trimming those black toe nails and the ensuing fracas! I can’t imagine reaching into one’s mouth on purpose! :wink:

[QUOTE=wendy;6741982]
We often freak out unnecessarily when we see our dogs gulping down huge chunks of food, but that’s how dogs naturally eat- they swallow large chunks of meat/bone, and then it gets digested. It’s normal for them to swallow huge chunks of food. As long it’s digestible, it will either dissolve in the stomach, or if it doesn’t dissolve, the dog will puke it up later. Usually you only get problems if the dog happens to swallow something that isn’t digestible. One of my dogs once swallowed an entire rabbit, fur, head, and all, and digested it just fine.

So the IMPORTANT thing is not that the dog swallows it, but that what the dog is swallowing is a digestible substance.

Nylabones aren’t safe at all- they aren’t digestible, and the company makes them so they don’t show up on x-rays so when your dog swallows a chunk of them and the gut is blocked by the chunk of plastic your vet won’t be able to see it.

AND NEVER EVER give your dog a smoked or boiled or cooked bone- the heating process renders the bone indigestible and brittle. Those smoked bones they sell in pet stores are dog-killers. They are brittle, thus the dog can break off pieces, which then get swallowed and can’t be digested because they are cooked.

Sometimes you’ll see cow hooves for sale- these don’t appear to be very digestible either, so perhaps best avoided. Rawhide is not very digestible so it’s best avoided.

Antlers are just bone- uncooked bone, thus digestible. Bully sticks, tendons, and tripe chews are digestible. Any uncooked raw bone should be digestible, but the sturdy weight-bearing leg bones of say cows are often so hard that the dog’s teeth might break- the softer joint ends (the knuckles) are safer than the hard shaft (marrow bones and the like). Frozen raw turkey necks make excellent chews for the smaller dogs- fully digestible, and take some chewing.

If you want the dog to spend time chewing rather than swallow it, get something bigger than the dog’s head so there’s no way it’s going down whole.[/QUOTE]

Things are only digestable if they make it to the stomach. For example, a highly digestable knucklebone that is stuck in the esophagus is not going to digest.

People are so worried about bones etc. making it through the intestines - uncooked bones are still a potential hazard. This christmas we had FOUR dogs with esophogeal foreign bodies, knucklebones, some sort of other soft raw bone and a christmas decoration. One was euthanized becasue the bone was in so long the esophagus became necrotic around the bone and perforated. It happens. Its not common, but it does so please be careful of what you choose to offer your dog.

Yep, that’s my worry – when I’ve had to retrieve things from my JRT’s throat, it was mid-choke. She gets them stuck and I’ve had to go fishing… one of those times was because my SO didn’t realize that Petrodex (dental treated rawhides) were in fact, rawhide…he thought they were “ok” and she of course did the gulp and choke… We had a corgi that could handle the rawhides so I kept them on hand for her, but now that she is gone, there aren’t any in the house to prevent SO from inadvertently using them!