This was a trip to read through again.
I gotta say, I’m surprised that during the lengthy discussion about show fees, it appears no one who does the numbers for recognized and non recognized events chimed in. I do not do the accounting for horse shows of any kind, but I do work for a company that sponsors a few events in my area every year and I assure you the problem is the land and the facilities.
These events are run at facilities that are on protected farm land or state parks that have been running their shows for eternity. “Legacy” farm if you will. The upkeep is constant, but the improvements that are costly are able to be spaced out over a reasonable amount of time. They add a couple of new cross country jumps every year, replace the footing one ring at a time, etc. So the financial investments that need to be made aren’t scary and all at once. A new facility cannot just pop up and offer a comparable event with safe footing and fences. Every single one of the six major show venues I can think of off the top of my head also run rated and schooling dressage shows, and most run hunter/jumper stuff too. So facilities are only sustainable if they make horse shows their business. And its not like these dressage and jumper shows subsidize eventing either, because the exact same conversations happen in those communities. Across the board, every ammature that works their butt off for their one or two horses thinks competing is too expensive. But the venues eek out just enough money that hosting is worth their while. US Equestrian and the FEI may be frustrating, but to break off from them entirely would hurt us more than it would hurt the governing organizations. For whatever “grassroots” organizations we would form, we’d still need to rent facilities ($$$ we wouldn’t have) or find a benefactor, and that’s not likely to happen.
For what its worth, I come from dressage, and event entries seem reasonable to me. They are a little more expensive, but I am getting so much more competition for my money that the increase feels justified. I also think its really cool that BIG BIG pros are at all the competitions with me. In dressage and hunter/jumperland the riders you idolize are sequestered in their own shows or their own area. But pony club kids near me warm up with Olympians and think its normal. I saw a video that Eventing Nation just shared of Blackfoot Mystery own in Texas with his ammy owner cruising around BN. That’s an OTTB that made it to the Olympics and is rideable enough to be piloted by a regular person (albeit a very wealthy person) at the lowest level. If that doesn’t prove that eventing is the most accessible discipline in this sport, I don’t know what will.
The only thing I will criticize USE for is the condonning of abusive behaviors at the tippy top. Blood where it shouldn’t be, horses and riders who are not fit enough to be running around a 5* course, etc. Unfortunately I think the ones who hold the power to make those riders face consequences are the owners and sponsors, not the governing bodies.