Help me pick chickens!

We bought our 10 acre farm 4 weeks ago, brought the horses home 2 weeks ago, and now I’m contemplating chickens!

I’m looking for a small flock of interesting to look at chickens that are good layers. I’m in Indiana so it gets up into the 90s during the summer and into the teens and occasionally single digits in the winter. I think it would be nice to have brown or colored eggs. I plan on housing them in a stall in the barn and free ranging them during the day.

Breed suggestions?

I’m looking at https://www.mypetchicken.com/catalog/Day-Old-Baby-Chicks-c36.aspx?HatchDate=next

They ship as few as 2 and have a lot of breeds available. I’d like a total of 4 - 6 females.

I can’t speak to the quality of the specific lines you can get at MPC, but of those, one I’d draw your attention to is the Buckeye. They are wonderful free rangers, people oriented, and really lovely in person. We have had them for years. They’re sturdy. They’re adequate but not brilliant egg layers. I know they have done well in both hot and cold climates.

If you want layers, consider the light brown leghorns. Terrific laying breed.

Barred Rocks also are a good choice.

The brown layer assortment might be a fun way to go too. Then, you have a lot of different birds to look at.

1 Like

Definitely toss in some Ameraucana / Easter Eggers if they have them. Blue eggs are fun. :slight_smile:

1 Like

I had 7 Barred Rocks- excellent layers, friendly and just all around nice chickens. The more you handle them as babies, the friendlier they are when they’re older. If you plan to free range them, teach them to go back to their stall
the same time every evening and soon they will ‘put’ themselves up. So you don’t have to chase them to put them away. When you go out to give treats, call them and it’s hilarious how they come running out of nowhere when you
call them. Oh, I really miss my girls. Good Luck with yours.

Leghorns are the best layers, bar none.
They are gentle ones, less cannibalism than most, have a long layer life.

Others may be prettier, have more personality, but for laying, they are the best.

As pets, all bets are off then with all kinds of breeds out there, to please any preference.

I agree! I loved my easter eggers. They are very good layers and produce excellent quality eggs.

1 Like

I’m hoping to do the same thing at some point, as far as using a stall for chickens. Are there any issues about housing chickens and equines (who really won’t be in the stalls much)?

There will be chicken poop everywhere. My coop is nowhere near my barn.

3 Likes

@Palm Beach is right :no:
Chickens poop wherever they happen to be standing.
I have sufficient Starling, Sparrow & Swallow poop in my barn - no need to add hens to the mix :dead:

That said, I love my hens & when they freeranged they did visit the barn & pastures.
Very low maintenance pets & they make you breakfast!

IIWM I’d go to your local TSC or Rural King for chicks.
Waaay cheaper than MPC & they are starting to have some variety.
Also you avoid the heartbreak of getting dead or dying chicks in the box,
Yeah, I know they have some sort of replacement policy, but for less than $3/ea you can take home live sexed chicks.
No need for a rooster & a lot of them get nasty when they hit puberty.

I’m in IN too and never had a problem with hens surviving bitter Winters in my unheated coop.
I do provide a heatlamp in the worst weather, but they rarely roost near it.
Remember: they wear down jackets 24/7/365 :wink:
Summers haven’t been a problem either - they are smart enough to stay as cool as possible.

As for breeds, I have had (all brown egglayers):
Delaware - large handsome white with barring, great layers & pretty friendly
Black Stars - shiny (like a beetle) black hens bred as layers, not so friendly
AmeraucanaX - never laid anything but brown, but she was a pretty bird
Currently an AmishX = likely Barred Rock & ??? - white hens with here & there black feathers

& just for fun, my only white egg layer: a Houdan - mottled black & white with a crest & more upright than most breeds.
In spite of the breed description “flighty”, this was my Pet Chicken, she followed me around & liked to be carried.
Not much of a layer - to her eggs were a gift more than an obligation :rolleyes:

2 Likes

I really like my crested cream legbars. They’re so friendly and really entertaining. They lay blue eggs and are auto sexing at hatch, so no chance of getting a boy.

For dark brown eggs, you’ll want a marans or two. They’re also sweet birds, but a little less outgoing, ime.

But also consider finding good local breeders, or shipping chicks from breeders, or shipping eggs from breeders and hatching. In general, the quality of the birds is profoundly better than from hatcheries. Not sure if it really matters to you, but I’m pretty stunned at the difference in the birds I have from various different breeders and my neighbor’s flock of hatchery birds from Tractor Supply. My Pet Chicken also sources from hatcheries around the US.

1 Like

I currently have five 14 month old hens from My Pet Chicken: Easter Egger, Golden Buff, Cuckoo Marans, Golden Laced Wyandotte, and Black Australorp. I’ve also previously had a California Grey.

The California Grey (a white leghorn mix) laid the most eggs but they were white. She recently kicked the bucket at 7 years old.

The Cuckoo Marans started off strong, but hasn’t laid an egg in a while. I suspect she might have some sort of reproductive defect. The eggs she did lay were huge. I had another Cuckoo marans in the past, and she was especially prone to going broody. While both laid darker than average eggs, they weren’t dark enough to be anything special. I don’t think I’ll get any more.

The Easter Egger is a consistent layer of nice large minty green eggs. She started out as the most flighty of the bunch, but has become bolder.

The Golden Laced Wyandotte and Black Australorp are also very consistent layers, but their eggs are on the smaller side and a lighter brown. The Black Australorp lays very light brown eggs - more of a beige, and she is pretty friendly.

The Golden Buff is a consistent layer of large brown eggs, and is the most outgoing of the bunch.

All of my chicks arrived healthy (early May delivery) and all were correctly sexed as pullets. [ATTACH=JSON]{“data-align”:“none”,“data-size”:“large”,“data-attachmentid”:10184559}[/ATTACH]

eggs.jpg

I love my Barred Rock hens. Something about the pattern of their feathers reminds me of the dresses church ladies used to wear. :slight_smile: Friendly, hardy, good layers.
My Americaunas lay beautiful colored eggs, and I get a kick out of their green feet. :slight_smile: They are kind of wild-acting though. I free-range so this is actually a plus for me - the tamer the chicken the shorter its lifespan seems to be on the farm.
Rhode Island Reds (RIRs) are also good layers and easy keepers.
My Buff Orps are beautiful, friendly girls but don’t lay as prolifically as the other breeds. And they are BROOODY. This time of year I keep peck-marks on the backs of my hands from reaching under these girls. Otherwise I’d never get any eggs!
I agree Leghorns are egg-laying machines.:yes: For some reason, though, the hawks seem to take them out before the others. Maybe because they’re white and make a good target?
My favorite chickens so far are Silver Laced Wyandottes. I only have one left now - Melania (so named because she is pretty, not because of any political reason, I promise!). She’s the last one left because, noted above, the tamer the chicken the shorter the life span. But they are beautiful, and good layers, and friendly to people. Blanche, my favorite chicken of all time, would actually walk up and ask to be petted.
I get mine from the feed store. If you order, you have to order a couple of dozen don’t you?

Why not have a look at the Livestock Conservancy webpage and find a rare heritage breed? They tend to suit non-commercial farms and you would be saving a bit of history.

2 Likes

I’ve had RIR, red sex linked, leg horn, and barred rocks. The barred rocks are definitely my favorite, tend to be friendly, kind, and not too stupid. The RIR and leg horns were less tame, and less smart about potential predators.

Chickens help a lot with insect control, and clean up any spilled feed so there’s less available for rodents. And they’re little garbage disposals…will eat any table scraps or leftovers, and are hilarious when they come running!

I haven’t had chickens for a while, but really want to get some again.
I loved my Barred Rocks, so pretty and friendly, and my RIRs - which would run to me when I walked toward the barn and jump up in my arms. I also had Buff Orpingtons and they were lovely birds too.

They are wonderful little critters, I love the way they work around the farm dig around the manure pile, and they love leftovers - especially things like peaches! rice!
And yes, nothing better than home-grown fresh eggs…

Let us know what you decide, OP.

I looked at those first on Mypetchicken, and they were very expensive for day old chicks for someone with no experience.

1 Like

Yeah, if you want really dark eggs, you’re not going to get that from hatchery marans. Breeders are even reluctant to let their 7+ egg color eggs go, but you’ll get darker eggs from people who actually breed for that.

@EnjoyThe Ride I also debated cheap “starter” chickens because holy cow I have no clue what I’m doing. But got sucked into the world of nicer birds from breeders and then wound up hatching my own (buying incubators for a fraction of new $$ on ebay and local FB sales.) It is a BLAST to hatch your own! And despite my ignorance, I only lost one baby chick out of more than 30. Her death is still perplexing to me, but really might have just been “one of those things.” My ratio was slightly more than 50/50 boys/girls, but I’ve managed to sell (for MONEY! :lol:) eight roosters. Five need to be butchered soon, and four probably are next up in 4-6 weeks, if I can’t get them sold. I have several really nice pullets who should start laying in the next couple months and they’re just so much nicer than the hatchery birds I’ve seen around.

Something else that I’ve noticed is breeder birds seem to be friendlier. Hatcheries aren’t really selecting for anything but volume. They don’t care if the hens are friendly or the roosters are assholes. Breeders generally interact with their birds more and select for tractability.

There are a lot of chicken FB pages that should allow you to connect with breeders local to you, if you’re interested, or find people who will ship you eggs or chicks.

Chickens In a stall will invite mice, rats, snakes. You really want a separate coop surrounded by hardware cloth.

2 Likes

Chickens need to be put up at night in a structure that a raccoon cannot get into. That rules out a horse stall, unless you’re planning to build a coop of some sort within the stall. For any parts of your coop that are not a solid material like wood, use heavy-duty hardware cloth . Chicken wire, woven wire fencing, etc are all easily defeated by raccoons.

I’m in Iowa, so similar climate extremes, and have had lots of different breeds without any problems. Depends on what structure you’re going to use as a coop, of course. Our coop building has thick wood siding, and is big enough that they can perch well away from the building walls and any drafts. In deep winter, they huddle together on the various perches and keep each other warm. They do just fine. In the summer, be sure to run a (safe!!) fan in the coop to keep air moving and reduce gnat problems.

I’ve used Murray McMurray Hatchery for ordering chicks and they’ve always done a great job.

The orpingtons and the australorps are all large birds with luxurious, glossy feathers-- Very pretty even though they’re “just” solid-colored .

For just whimsical fun, add a couple polish hens. The eggs are small, but you won’t get tired of their jaunty top-hat appearance.

The Americaunas are kind of mutts, they can be any color. But they tend to be interesting --I think they’re fierce-looking.

Breeds with "laced’ wing patterns tend to be very pretty – check out the Wyandotts.

I had a trio of Columbian Rock hens, good layers and the black/white feather patterns were beautiful.

I’d avoid blue andalusians – I got sucked into them for the beautiful dusty blue colored feathers, but the eggs shells were paper-thin and break easily.

2 Likes

Luckily I have a row of stalls in my detached indoor that I don’t use, so we are weighing the costs of predator proofing one of those or building a coop.