Horse sent to Mill Creek farm Retirement not doing well!

I have to laugh…my sister when talking about my SKINNY 96 yo mother just says ’ she’s old - what do you expect’ . Maybe I should be outraged that she is so skinny. Actually she is doing pretty darned well for her age but I do talk with the caregivers and ask that they give her something different if she doesn’t like today’s food because she needs the calories and is a picky eater.

Max is , of course, running off calories in his stressed out change of circumstance. I would also guess he has ulcers and with his bad teeth he isn’t getting the nutrition out of the food given. The removal of supplementation isn’t the cause of the weight loss…but it prob. doesn’t help. I guess I would feel better if someone just acknowledged that he looks like crap! Then I would feel better that they are looking into WHY! But saying he hasn’t lost more than 50#?? sigh!

I guess I would add alfalfa pellets rather than more complete Sr. and then beet pulp and hay stretcher if alfalfa isn’t right. Of course I would be giving him soaked feed…but I have WAAAY fewer horses and can give obsessive individual attention. I don’t have the expertise to evaluate content and balance of feed program…but I tend to like basic foods ( oats, grass, hay or hay pellets) and specific vitamin supplementation rather than grain (esp corn)based feeds with vitamins incl’d. Way too much Cushings today from bad feeding programs IMO. I was guilty!! I believed.

Vet also doesn’t say WHICH Sr. feed - there is a big difference in Sr feeds IMO. Also dry vs. soaked may make a difference in his ability to absorb the nutrients.

Overall MC is a lovely place - let’s not string them up on the nearest tree. Think of it as a nursing home for equines. It IS a place where end of life happens and maybe EVERYTHING doesn’t need to be fixed. I plan to visit when I return to FL.

And Mijo has been there for 12 years? Poor guy :frowning:

[QUOTE=LauraKY;7219198]
I don’t think it’s a conspiracy, I think it’s group denial. The butterflies and rainbows syndrome…horses should be FREE to roam in green pastures.

Take a look at this one at Mill Creek. Go all the way to the bottom of the page and click on Milo. Tell me what you think. Max isn’t the only horse in trouble, Milo
“…he is able to get around by hopping on three legs.”

http://www.millcreekfarm.org/someofourhorses.html[/QUOTE]

I had Windy, the wonder QH here for a couple of years. He was the Canadian Champion Barrel Racing Division in his youth and his owner placed him with a young girl in Montana who was going to learn from him etc.

He was about 20 at that time and was a great starter horse.

Of course the agreement…should they ever decide to get rid of him…an so on…She received a call from a lady in Montana saying the thought the old guy, ready to go through the sale (next day) was her old barrel horse. Mad Dash…purchased him and brought him back to Canada

He was at a few farms before I was approached. He was about 50-75 pounds under weight. Like this horse…he was a weaver and stall walker.

It took him one year…from age 31 to 32 to quit weaving. He also dropped more weight after he arrived here as he was put on into a small grass field with a young filly for company. It took that period of time in addition to a girl friend to change his behaviour.

He did NOT respond to any seniors food and we tried them all. He did respond to a simple rolled oats with molasses and soft beet pulp. His teeth were floated, regular farrier work and a blanket suitable for the cold weather and sheets during the summer.

The owner wanted to put him on additional powdered vitamines but the vet said no. He gave the same reason…oldsters already have a comprimised digestive system and the more “foreign” stuff you put into them causes kidney and intestinal problems

Over the next few years he stopped weaving, enjoyed his all day out even when it was forty below F. He passed away, in October two years ago, in his stall…no struggle…we presume he died in his sleep.

He was 34.

The only “exception” made for him feed wise, other than what the vet recommended was cooked oats during the winter and a mash weekly, again, during the winter.

Sometimes we want them to regain their youth…and we are all victims of great advertising. We THINK a supplement is necessary when it isn’t. We are used to over medicating ourselves with vitamines and other products because we believe they help us or give us energy.

This vet has stated clearly…they have tested for cell count etc and he has looked at blood work and fecal deposits. THOSE tests are relevant and most certainly are more accurate than our appraisals based on emotion and just looking at the animal.

Any group…DEFHR, GG, Paradise do not want volunteers who will verbally trash their program…and so…they eliminate those who are critical of their proceedures.

It sounds like many of the negative comments and reference to the owners ages etc are unwarranted. Of course it is great to check them out…and from the comments posted, by the attending Vet…it sounds like they do have an ongoing process.

IF we want 24 / 7 individual care and we want to be our own vet, then we should not donate, give away a horse to anyone. Only when it is under our direct supervision can we then smile and say…he is alive because of me.

No different than folks who put Mom and or Dad into a nursing home.

My Dad had an attendant at home for as long as we could keep him there…and he still had “dirty” depends…when he was moved to a small intimate facility…I was critical based on emotion…not facts and reality. As Dad slowly integrated into the mileu of the home…it was easier on him…but we still did not believe it was “up to what we would provide”.

In hind sight…it was actually better than what we provided…He still had visitors and outings…but more important…like for the horse…there was ongoing change and stimulation.

Maybe people should have first hand visits to a facility before they try and destroy it. Hearsay and rumours may engage one into thinking they are actually doing something productive…but they do have an impact.

would love to hear the vet’s justification for the one hopping on 3 legs. Head/desk.

Bottom line: these people need to be shut down, but Max needs to get out of there before anyone can focus on that.

[QUOTE=JackieBlue;7219173]
While I agree that the horse in unacceptable condition in the latest photo, the anhydrosis thing confuses me. He’s in FL, yes? And the vet says he’s been pacing and weaving? And he hasn’t overheated in his pasture environment that he’s been in for months now? He must be sweating some, no? It sounds as if he’s been on OneAC for years. Has he ever had ACTH or any other potential curative for the condition?
It sounds as if the supplements that were discontinued by the retirement farm were OneAC, a coat supp and Red Cell. Aside from possibly OneAC (although there are other treatments for anhydrosis that don’t require daily feed supplementation), none of these is essential. Both the coat supp and the Red Cell added calories, but not enough to see such a dip in condition from discontinuation. If the horse isn’t anemic (and, according to the vet, he’s not, even after 12 or so weeks off Red Cell), then continuing Red Cell is just an unnecessary expense. And, of course, the coat supp is an aesthetic product, not necessary for the health of an oldster. The senior feed he’s on should be balanced with respect to vitamins and minerals, so further supplementation of those, in the absence of proof of deficiency is unnecessary and can even prove harmful.
Yes, the horse is skinny, but it’s not because he’s not getting his supps. The vet’s explanation of increased activity and stress over relocation and routine change seems reasonable. Again, I agree that this horse’s condition in the photo is deplorable. But I’m not ready to start tying the noose. Maybe the new feeding plan the vet described will have a positive effect. At 32 years old, it doesn’t seem odd for a major change in living conditions to have an effect on the horse. Can someone go back and take new photographs for you in a few weeks to see how he’s adjusting? I can’t imagine the retirement farm owners will be too keen on letting anyone with a camera near this horse now, but maybe…[/QUOTE]

Hi JB,

Since you brought it up. The horse has been chronically anhidrotic that has worsened as the horse aged. In his early years through late teens , One AC , dark beer and acupuncture kept him sweating at least while under saddle a modest amount. Enough to allow the horse to have competitive career.

As he’s aged those have had less and less of an impact but he seemed to be more uncomfortable when taken off One AC so per his life long vet he was left on it.

The Red Cell and Coat supplement (first I’m hearing of that) were additions to his routine during the year he spent outside of our care. That BO says they were initiated by Max’s long time vet.

When he left our care the only supplementation besides Triple Crown Senior that he was getting was Rice Bran and a multi vite/electrolyte supplement over the summer.

Their assumptive nature that the horse’s vices were caused by being kept in a stall are simply untrue and unfounded. If anything his chronic mud fever in the summers was exasperated by our instance that he receive turn out even if it meant only at night when the grass is dewy.

As for overheating I have no idea if anyone has the ablity there to recognize what a hyperthermic horse might look like. For Max he pants and spends an extraordinary amount of time self cooling by splashing in a water source.

The horse came to us as an 8 or 9 year old with all of the vices described. He cribbed , he weaved and paced if he was stressed or not kept in the company of other horses.

He was put on a high forage diet and checked for ulcers and treated even at one point profilactiacally just to see if it might help.

I suspect they were and are remnants of his 4 years on the track.

The horses activity has not increased he’s always been turned out almost 24/7 in reasonable temperatures and only in during the peak hours of the day in the summer.

I am not saying the vets diagnosis of stress/relocation and change in living condition is not the reason for his weight loss. I am saying IT is. Things the facility owners were made aware that they would affect the horse and to be wary of it months ago.

As per their feeding plan. Max is a grain nibbler if they are feeding him 10lbs of senior BID and he lives with another horse un segregated at meal time he’s not eating all of that grain I’d bet life on it. He routinely took hours to finish a grain meal of half that size in our care … I bet his pasture mate is tick fat.

All I have ever wanted or asked for is to be allowed to fill in the holes in the horses history and help them allow him to thrive. I’ve got 20 years of experience and when he left our care he was a vibrant healthy for his age older animal.

He was NEVER kept locked in a stall as they keep repeating or presuming. His vices have been life long issues that wax an wane depending on the environment provided. I don’t doubt for a moment if they threw him in a field alone that he weaved and paced until he was given a companion. It seems common horse sense would put two and two together not make wild assumptions about his past.

I don’t want to vilify anyone I just want Max to be given the best care possible and was willing to take him back and provide it if he was not thriving in their care (which based on the photos’ he has declined)

Prior to reaching out here I emailed and called the facility when I learned about the horses condition and was met with only negative response.

This is a copy of the mail I sent upon learning of his condition. I have NEVER gotten any response from MC and at that point had to believe it was in Max’s best interest to contact the authorities.

There are gaps in their knowledge and history of the horse I’ve always been willing to fill them in provide his records and anything necessary to aid the horse.

Yes I would have preferred that Max had been returned to my care by the BO but since things had progressed beyond that I was and am very grateful and happy to have Mill Creek looking after the horse as long as he thrives in their program. If he’s not I’d happily take him back.

[h=1]"How do we work together for the horse.

[/h][I]Mr. and Mrs Gregory and staff at Mill Creek,

First I wanted to thank you for your on going care of my former horse Max.

As I am sure you are aware it has been brought to my attention that Max is not holding his weight and thriving as we all would have hoped in your wonderful program.

When he was remanded to you 12 weeks ago I contacted you hoping to explain that he simply is a horse that because of his medical history doesn’t flourish a field board situation. He is a unique case being both a cribber and having anhidrosis.

I know you are doing everything you can for him and his history is not well known to you. I am more then happy to release the last 22 years of his medical history to your veterinarian if it would help her understand his conditions , what medications he was on and why and make choices going forward.

I very much appreciate the care you have given Max and want to do anything I can to help you find solutions to combat his weight loss. I can assure you that if he’s able to crib/windsuck in combination with the hot FL summers because of his inability to sweat most certainly have contributed greatly to his weight loss. They are issues we had to manage all 22 years we owned him .

I do want to make it perfectly clear that I would be happy to take Max back into my ownership and allow my team of veterinarians to asses him an see if we can’t get him back on a road with positive gains. Please know that option always exists. Potentially opening up a space for you to take in a horse that doesn’t have anyone to look after him.

Again please let me know, let me work with you to help Max. His well being is all that is important to me. I don’t hold anyone in blame and I just would like to be there to help you and your team.

I hope to hear from you and will be following up soon. "[/I]

We discussed his previous treatment with one AC, which according to the person whom last had possession of the horse never produced any results and red cell as well as his coat supplement.The plan we formulated for max was to place him in a pasture with grass that also had a large amount of shade available for him and to place water in the shade so on warm days he would not be stressed.

So glad this vet decreed that his change from a cool stall, to a field in Florida in July isn’t stress. :no:

and that this is always the case - just turn a cribber out!

He also had some behavioral issues such as weaving, cribbing and pacing which many times are associated with horses that have been stalled and bored for too much of their lives.

And we know he got all his feed when…

We decided to wait and see if his behavior would improve being in a pasture with another horse for company.

Do they honestly note those not eating with over 100 head?!?

OK, let’s just say NO ONE is to blame. At the VERY least, it could just be the condition that the horse is extremely depressed having been moved to a new location, and will not eat, nor will he thrive there.

Returning him is an absolutely logical alternative. As is putting him to sleep rather than using him for an experiment in what will/will not work.

We’re led to believe that the horse had, as the previous poster put it, “a specialized care/routine”, but then the vet cites cellulitis, rain rot and scratches. He also states that the horse was underweight upon arrival and cribbed, paced and weaved. I just don’t feel well acquainted with the actual facts here and I wonder if anyone is. How long was he at his last barn between abandonment and being sent to Mill Creek? What was his level of care during his period of abandonment? It just doesn’t sound like Mill Creek got a pristine horse and let it go to shit. Granted, his condition in the last photo is horrid, but perhaps treating his various conditions and adjusting to new surroundings were hard on him. Has anyone watched the horse at feeding time at Mill Creek? Can someone go visit him and observe him for a length of time? How can anyone make assumptions like “the horse is extremely depressed” when no one posting has spent any length of time observing his behavior?

Folks…have a go at it. Rather than assume the horse is not fed, treated etc…go and see for yourself instead of continuing to slag the current placement.

A picture is NEVER the story…I have pictures of Windy that made him look emaciated and also others that hid his hipbones and made him look like an 18 year old.

OMG I just lost it in my office :lol:

[QUOTE=Lynnwood;7219251]
Hi JB,

Since you brought it up. The horse has been chronically anhidrotic that has worsened as the horse aged. In his early years through late teens , One AC , dark beer and acupuncture kept him sweating at least while under saddle a modest amount. Enough to allow the horse to have competitive career.

As he’s aged those have had less and less of an impact but he seemed to be more uncomfortable when taken off One AC so per his life long vet he was left on it.

The Red Cell and Coat supplement (first I’m hearing of that) were additions to his routine during the year he spent outside of our care. That BO says they were initiated by Max’s long time vet.

When he left our care the only supplementation besides Triple Crown Senior that he was getting was Rice Bran and a multi vite/electrolyte supplement over the summer.

Their assumptive nature that the horse’s vices were caused by being kept in a stall are simply untrue and unfounded. If anything his chronic mud fever in the summers was exasperated by our instance that he receive turn out even if it meant only at night when the grass is dewy.

As for overheating I have no idea if anyone has the ablity there to recognize what a hyperthermic horse might look like. For Max he pants and spends an extraordinary amount of time self cooling by splashing in a water source.

The horse came to us as an 8 or 9 year old with all of the vices described. He cribbed , he weaved and paced if he was stressed or not kept in the company of other horses.

He was put on a high forage diet and checked for ulcers and treated even at one point profilactiacally just to see if it might help.

I suspect they were and are remnants of his 4 years on the track.

The horses activity has not increased he’s always been turned out almost 24/7 in reasonable temperatures and only in during the peak hours of the day in the summer.

I am not saying the vets diagnosis of stress/relocation and change in living condition is not the reason for his weight loss. I am saying IT is. Things the facility owners were made aware that they would affect the horse and to be wary of it months ago.

As per their feeding plan. Max is a grain nibbler if they are feeding him 10lbs of senior BID and he lives with another horse un segregated at meal time he’s not eating all of that grain I’d bet life on it. He routinely took hours to finish a grain meal of half that size in our care … I bet his pasture mate is tick fat.

All I have ever wanted or asked for is to be allowed to fill in the holes in the horses history and help them allow him to thrive. I’ve got 20 years of experience and when he left our care he was a vibrant healthy for his age older animal.

He was NEVER kept locked in a stall as they keep repeating or presuming. His vices have been life long issues that wax an wane depending on the environment provided. I don’t doubt for a moment if they threw him in a field alone that he weaved and paced until he was given a companion. It seems common horse sense would put two and two together not make wild assumptions about his past.

I don’t want to vilify anyone I just want Max to be given the best care possible and was willing to take him back and provide it if he was not thriving in their care (which based on the photos’ he has declined)[/QUOTE]

A horse requiring a lifetime of medication and intervention should never have been given away to anyone. Dark Beer and acupuncture from an early age…And, red cell…maybe there were ongoing blood tests to confirm its necessity or maybe the vet just said…yeah…continue to give it…it is not doing him any harm and might keep him stable…instead of doing the necessary bloodwork…well…I am sure he had his reasons…maybe the owner didn’t want to pay for all of the tests…

You had the horse when he was eight or nine…and he had all of those vices. A lifetime of those behaviours is going to take its toll…AND he is very very very and again VERY OLD.

Any change is going to impact him.

OP, he was remanded to Mill Creek by a court? If so, I’d say any doubts about ownership, as discussed earlier, would be moot.

[QUOTE=JackieBlue;7219259]
We’re led to believe that the horse had, as the previous poster put it, “a specialized care/routine”, but then the vet cites cellulitis, rain rot and scratches. He also states that the horse was underweight upon arrival and cribbed, paced and weaved. I just don’t feel well acquainted with the actual facts here and I wonder if anyone is. How long was he at his last barn between abandonment and being sent to Mill Creek? What was his level of care during his period of abandonment? It just doesn’t sound like Mill Creek got a pristine horse and let it go to shit. Granted, his condition in the last photo is horrid, but perhaps treating his various conditions and adjusting to new surroundings were hard on him. Has anyone watched the horse at feeding time at Mill Creek? Can someone go visit him and observe him for a length of time? How can anyone make assumptions like “the horse is extremely depressed” when no one posting has spent any length of time observing his behavior?[/QUOTE]

JB

It was a year between leaving our care and going to Mill Creek. The place he was kept is a small private boarding facility with a great reputation. Who insists the horse only had the same chronic mud fever/dew poison that we combated with the horse EVERY summer for over a decade. He was being treated currently for it.

As per his “cellulitis” did you LOOK at the photos? He’s a 32 year old TB that raced for 4 years and then was a Eq horse a Jumper and then a schooling horse. He stocks up behind PERIOD.
Please point to me in this photo and show me cellulits ? This is moments after he arrived at Mill Creek. Perhaps something sprung up after he got there but he did not arrive with ANYTHING besides dew poisoning. All I see is an older sport horse with wind puffy /stocked up hind fetlocks.

http://oi41.tinypic.com/34ovbkz.jpg

The farm he came from is Rose Apple Stables it is a small private facility with mostly retired horses and a few dressage and trail riders mixed in. There was no gab in the horses care. The BO immediately assumed care for the horse he wasn’t abandoned in the sense of the word his board was not being paid.

Here is her website if you want to critic or pick at her facility.
http://roseapplestables.com/Rose_Apple_Stables/Welcome_to_Rose_Apple.html

Jackie, please read the thread through before asking the OP to restate things that are already known.

see in the first post:

When our family sold our boarding/training facility one of our former students asked to take a particular schooling horse to retire him. We agreed. He was at that time 29 and mostly retired anyway taught a few walk lessons for small kids…went on a few trail rides.

There was some checking for the first 6 months horse was thriving.

Fast forward to two months ago I was informed through a local vet that he had been abandoned by the person who took him at his boarding facility and they had made arrangements to transfer him to a retirement facility in the state that takes in government horses and abandoned horses.

The OP did not give him to this facility. He was surrendered by the boarding facility at which he had been living AFTER the OP’s farm retired him to the ownership of a past student. She only learned of this series of events after the horse was in the hands of Mill Creek and not doing well.

[QUOTE=Fairfax;7219283]
A horse requiring a lifetime of medication and intervention should never have been given away to anyone. Dark Beer and acupuncture from an early age…And, red cell…maybe there were ongoing blood tests to confirm its necessity or maybe the vet just said…yeah…continue to give it…it is not doing him any harm and might keep him stable…instead of doing the necessary bloodwork…well…I am sure he had his reasons…maybe the owner didn’t want to pay for all of the tests…

You had the horse when he was eight or nine…and he had all of those vices. A lifetime of those behaviours is going to take its toll…AND he is very very very and again VERY OLD.

Any change is going to impact him.[/QUOTE]

Fairfax I’m going to attempt t be polite with you. Attempt.

He was NOT just willy nilly given away. When our facility closed a student who had ridden and had a relationship with the horse over years asked if she might be allowed to take over his care in retirement. A small private facility with someone who for years at been loyal to the horse seemed like the PERFECT situation.

The rest of our retire’s are living very much in a field board situation with run ins and grass fields still owned by us. We knew the horse well enough to know he’d struggle in that environment and THAT IS WHY we went another route with him. Max was THE ONLY horse we allowed to go into someone else’s care because at the time it was BEST for him. The other alternative would have been to euthanize him…he’s not a horse suited for a field in hot FL 24/7.

That student suddenly flaking out and literally leaving town /vanishing on the BO was not something we ever would have considered and he went with a return for any reason clause. To this date I have not been able to locate said person nor make any headway on WHY she didn’t contact anyone and flaked out.

[QUOTE=JackieBlue;7219259]
We’re led to believe that the horse had, as the previous poster put it, “a specialized care/routine”, but then the vet cites cellulitis, rain rot and scratches. He also states that the horse was underweight upon arrival and cribbed, paced and weaved. I just don’t feel well acquainted with the actual facts here and I wonder if anyone is. How long was he at his last barn between abandonment and being sent to Mill Creek? What was his level of care during his period of abandonment? It just doesn’t sound like Mill Creek got a pristine horse and let it go to shit. Granted, his condition in the last photo is horrid, but perhaps treating his various conditions and adjusting to new surroundings were hard on him. Has anyone watched the horse at feeding time at Mill Creek? Can someone go visit him and observe him for a length of time? How can anyone make assumptions like “the horse is extremely depressed” when no one posting has spent any length of time observing his behavior?[/QUOTE]

Jackie, take a look at the photos on the day he was delivered to Mill Creek. I can only assume the vet saw him several weeks after he arrived.

[QUOTE=LauraKY;7219334]
Jackie, take a look at the photos on the day he was delivered to Mill Creek. I can only assume the vet saw him several weeks after he arrived.[/QUOTE]

This horse http://oi41.tinypic.com/34ovbkz.jpg

did not have "cellulitis, rain rot and scratches."

These are Dr. Barabas comments about the horse read them and then look at the photo which was taken POST a 5hr trailer ride to their facility.

These are taken directly from the email she sent Sue " At this time he was already underweight but our main concern was chronic wounds on his legs that had resulted in a cellulitis. He showed no signs of heart or lung issues and also had rain rot and scratches in multiple location"; “He also had some behavioral issues such as weaving, cribbing and pacing which many times are associated with horses that have been stalled and bored for too much of their lives”

This one leaves me scratching my head "It should be noted that his coat was not in good quality when he arrived"

Look at the photo of the horse…his coat is short and shiney and other then some dirt on his back no obvious way he could be described as she did.

yes, if we didn’t have a photo of the horse immediately prior to arriving @ Mill Creek, then this wouldn’t have the teeth it does. Pics aren’t perfect, but one cannot deny the volumes that these speak.

I’ve been trying to keep up with this thread, so I apologize if I missed this information somewhere. Since you seem to be hitting so many brick walls, has anyone contacted the media? Such as the Gainesville Sun. It’s the big newspaper in that area and covers Alachua.

Try Morgan Watkins?
http://www.gainesville.com/personalia/morganwatkins

Nothing creates awareness of something like this like media coverage. And newspaper reporters are tenacious.

[QUOTE=froglander;7219419]
I’ve been trying to keep up with this thread, so I apologize if I missed this information somewhere. Since you seem to be hitting so many brick walls, has anyone contacted the media? Such as the Gainesville Sun. It’s the big newspaper in that area and covers Alachua.

Try Morgan Watkins?
http://www.gainesville.com/personalia/morganwatkins

Nothing creates awareness of something like this like media coverage. And newspaper reporters are tenacious.[/QUOTE]

Unless someone knows an investigative reporter who is willing to do some research, contacting the media is fruitless. Both AC and the vet deny there is a management problem.

Just take a look at Milo at the bottom of the page I posted. He’s been there for 12 years according to their information and gets about by hopping on three legs. And he looks like crap ^2.

http://www.millcreekfarm.org/someofourhorses.html

The easy keepers seem to thrive. But the ones who aren’t…

All reporters are investigative. That’s the very nature of journalism. In this case, you have before and after photos, and once the reporter knows the lengths you’ve gone, they tend to question those authorities and ask them to justify their claims. You can’t know what will succeed or fail until you try, right?