When I was searching for a coach I would trailer my horse to their barn and take an ‘interview’ lesson. I call it this since not all coaches style/ideals match with every rider’s own style/ideals. (Note I am sure they all have some great material).
But anyways, in two of my lessons that I took with two different coaches, both competing with students in the 'A’s, they wanted me to keep short but soft rein, press my knuckles beside my horses mane and keep a very forward light seat.
I, personally, am big on theory and understanding concepts rather than just doing…(my background with a big eq barn), so I asked ‘why’. I was told that it encourages a lower outline since the horse will want to avoid the pressure. Resulting in the lopey hunter canter and will encourage the horse to keep their neck down over fences but tuck the knees up high to clear the rail.
It makes sense when I think about how it produces this reaction… but I didn’t end up staying with these coaches. Not really because of this but it was part.
(I have a younger greener horse who gets crafty if I stop riding to a fence. Ie- too many unplanned dismounts and unless I keep a feel with my seat she also stops making an effort. Likely because she is built a little long and needs a little assistance)
Ironically, on the other spectrum. I recently had a lesson with another new coach who told me my position was too perfect to stay effective.
But I get it… the outcome of your riding will be present in your horse. If you do not constantly adapt, your not doing your job to the fullest. So really, what does it matter what the rider looks like as long as it gets the best result?
I work in a field where I have to try to understand both sides and it kind of trickles into thinking of everything.
Although, I have to say I am in the boat of, “perfect equitation will teach the horse to meet you and be where it needs to be”.
I don’t think this is a controversial subject per say but I think different things work for different horses and people so that person gets set in their beliefs. My advice … Aim for the best equitation possible initially and once this is ingrained then try different things.
I should also note. I have a friend with a young hunter who is extremely athletic and round. He produces a phenominal jump when he is on his game but it also results in an extremely tough ride. I have been around the block a time or two and as much as I tried to stay beautiful, to stay out of his way resulted in a position … with less sparkle let’s say.
