A rope halter was not the problem here. Hard tieing was not the problem here. Poor horsemanship was the problem, if this happened as reported.
In light of all the “I’d never hard tie a horse” comments, I’m going to tell a story of a moment I’m not proud of that illustrates exactly why horses should be taught to hard tie, even if you never plan to actually do so.
I don’t generally hard tie my horses at home (because I don’t really need to - they ground tie), but it’s a skill I make sure to teach young horses very early. And I only use rope halters for everyday using. Mostly because I don’t have to worry about them getting wet, and I can make one halter fit every horse I own. The nice leather halters are reserved for shows and other extended road trips.
Two weeks ago, I hauled my broodmare to the vet for an ultrasound. When we got home, I unloaded her as I always do with my riding horse. Which means I pulled into my front yard (the barn isn’t accessible with a trailer), partially opened the escape door on my stock trailer to unclip her trailer tie and swap it for a - long, NH style - lead rope, and then walked to the back door to open it. I hopped in the trailer with her and asked her to back out, and she complied. Only AFTER she was fully unloaded did either of us realize that the tail of her lead rope was caught in the escape door of the trailer…
She was fully out of the trailer at this point. She started to sit back but quickly realized she was stuck. Between that and my quiet “whoa”, she stopped and stood still instead. Her good training and mind allowed me to remove the trailer tie from the trailer, walk to her, and replace her stuck lead rope with the trailer tie, which I used to lead her down the driveway to the barn.
Had she panicked, with the rope being so low, she’d have seriously injured herself. Had her lead rope been shorter, instead of the 12’ I use, she’d have hit the end of it while she was halfway out of the trailer and probably injured BOTH of us before we realized what was happening. Had she been wearing a breakaway halter, her initial yank would have resulted in a loose horse running panicked down a busy road.
This is why tie training is essential.
Disclaimer: I am in no way defending the subject of this post. But the error here had nothing to do with (properly) hard tieing a horse.