The complaint says Shannon Eckel has suffered great mental duress because of things people are saying? Are you kidding me? How about the mental duress that poor Cobain suffered? This woman is beyond horrible and I hope NOBODY uses her for training. How can people like this get up every day and look themselves in the mirror? I thought I had seen evil before but she takes the cake. Unbelievable 
16 Likes
Yes. For this horse - take the bedding out of the stall - though I still question whether anyone adequately fed horse would eat a lot of straw. So leave him there with a haynet filled with hay!
3 Likes
Itās almost all plastic these days. One time when my mare pulled back, the baling twine did not break; her halter did. She nearly flipped herself over in the process. Please note: she does not pull back habitually. It has happened 4 times in 17 years, and in all but one case it was because something scared her. Iām a huge fan of blocker rings as an alternative.
3 Likes
Can anyone post the lawsuit for us blocked-internationals?
Thatās the complaint filed on Eckelās behalf.
1 Like
Thank you! You are the MVP!!
3 Likes
@vxf111 What is you reaction to the complaint? Could there be an issue with Jurisdiction, and isnāt a conspiracy very difficult to prove?
1 Like
Sheās not alleging conspiracy: sheās got claims for defamation and IIED. I havenāt researched the applicable law so I canāt really opine whether he claims have merit. I will say that truth is a defense to defamation and IIED generally tends to be pretty challenging to plead/prove. Iām not barred in South Carolina and Iām not super familiar with their state tort law, and thatās what these claims areā state tort claims.
As for personal jurisdiction, again this is going to be in part based on what the state long arm statute says and how itās been interpreted. I assume all these statements were made online and that may make it easier to get jurisdiction in South Carolina where the effects of the alleged tort were felt. Arguably these defendants made purposeful contact with the state through online postings.
Itās really hard for me to say how viable this case is without doing more research. I will say that it draws Eckel back into the spotlight and I donāt know how great that is for her reputationā¦. But maybe she felt like she had to do something to stop people from posting about her?! I saw lots of posts about her recently. LOTS.
5 Likes
Thanks!
I see, it isnāt in the allegations proper. The words āConspiracyā and āconspiratorsā were thrown around quite a bit. I wonder what the purpose of that was.
1 Like
She appears to think these people colluded to post about her. I donāt know if they did or didnāt. I have seen a lot of posts about her lately and I donāt know whether itās a bunch of people posting independently or a group that got together to post. I donāt know any of these people but I have seen posts.
1 Like
The truth is an absolute defense in the 2 states where I was licensed. However, she probably had already sent cease & desist letters and this is the next step. Probably the plan is that it settles with a mutual gag order.
1 Like
Iām scarred for life after grooming for a WP trainer at the ripe age of 15-16 at Nationals, Worlds, and Reichart. I saw the most horrifying things on a daily basis.
Also (general), idk about any of you but getting near a horses FACE with a pocket knife while itās panicking (presumably because the person was justifying tying with a rope halter and having a pocket knife handy just in caseā¦) sounds like an absolutely horrific idea.
Big fat no in my book 
9 Likes
I donāt read any social media but the COTH forums, so I donāt see much.
I wonder if the lawsuit filed by the owner of the horse that died in her care was settled, or dropped. I suppose there must be some sort of record of the resolution, but I agree with you that if I was in her place, Iād not keep the incident in the forefront.
2 Likes
People stating that she āmurderedā a horse is silly and over the top. Horses arenāt āmurderedā they are killed.
She didnāt cut itās throat or shoot it, she apparently left it in a bad situation that caused it to panic and kill itself. The photos were horrific and it seems she does bear some responsibility for that.
2 Likes
That lawsuit (by Cobainās owner) appears to have settled.
3 Likes
Interesting that she used these words in her Facebook post:
It seems it never made it to court because it was settled. If it was settled in her favor it would be to her benefit to mention that, so it makes you wonder.
1 Like
Thereās no āprevailing partyā in a settlement. A settlement means the parties reached a mutually agreeable resolution without the court deciding a āwinnerā or a āloser.ā So I donāt know what she could say about the settlement, especially if its terms are confidential. I guess if the terms arenāt and she settled without paying any money she could say thatā¦ but she hasnāt and I donāt know if thatās because she did pay or because the terms are confidential. We donāt know.
3 Likes
Right. We donāt know, but she does. Not being a legal professional like you, I tend to think of a settlement in terms of which party (if any) had to pay, and if they did, the settlement was not in their favor.
I realize that some lawsuits are settled because the party or company being sued just wants to get rid of the nuisance, but itās hard to believe that is the case here. Still its curious that sheās keeping the dead horse in the news.
1 Like
I think most settlements are motivated by avoiding the uncertainty and cost of trial but that doesnāt mean a settling party doesnāt have a strong case. Nobody likes to pay attorneys 
and trials arenāt cheap.
I agree that keeping the allegations in the zeitgeist doesnāt seem like a terrific idea if you want them to go away but my perception was that chatter about Cobain was growing not shrinking (just my perception) so maybe she felt like she had to do something?! I donāt know.
2 Likes
