[QUOTE=gaitedincali;7303567]
I’ve tried all the “better” brands over the years and haven’t found that the higher price is justified in increased durability or comfort, but of course YMMV. I keep going back to Ariats and Justins, whichever it priced the best when I’m looking.[/QUOTE]
This has been my experience, too. I have a pair of Justin Gypsy boots, this style http://s.stpost.com/eccstorefront/product_images/5319g/f_5319g_1.1.jpg. They WILL. NOT. DIE. I don’t especially love riding in them, but it’s more of an ankle support thing than a sole issue. I muck stalls in them, bathe horses in them, walk through mud, etc. I’ve never oiled or treated them in any way and the leather still looks as good as the day I bought them. The suede has darkened a bit, but I don’t tuck my jeans into my boots, so I don’t really care what they look like. After five (yes, five) years of near daily wear, the only thing that is starting to wear out is the sole.
I’ve owned many pairs of “good” boots, and they all wore out much faster than my $70 Justins, with much lighter use (only worn to ride/show, no mucking, no washracks and certainly no mud :D). I do find the designs on the more expensive boots to be really cool, though.