NEW Barisone Court Filing - 7/15/21

[MHM]

@MorganSercu

That dog would have been seized in my state, taken to the local animal shelter and the owner would be facing serious and expensive legal costs to prevent it from being destroyed. The fact that the dog was within its house would be a mitigating factor but it may not outweigh the severity of the wound. With luck, it could be kept but with a lot of steps to be taken (8 foot high fencing, to be muzzled when not on the owner’s property, to always be leashed and under control of someone 16+ years old when outdoors,

That’s pretty much exactly what happened to someone I knew with a dog that bit a person, except for the part about moving to a different state.

[Marla_100]

Here’s my question.

How is her appearance of any legal relevance? Two different times she’s referred to as an “attractive blond woman.” What does that have to do with anything?

Is the implication that the male (?) police officers were influenced by her looks?

I read that as " she was so blond and attractive the witless horseman was taken in by her beauty and failed to use common sense in dealing with her due to his precarious emotional trauma as a child."

[Dee-Vee]

While I read through the whole post, thank you for posting, how much onus is on Barisone (prosecution) to substantiate the allegations, and how? For example, the parts concerning his reaction during the 911 calls and the behavior of the defendants when he spoke with them at the police station seem subjective?

Or is this just a piece to set the stage for the trials…in other words establish certain proof points of his mental state, behavior of LK, effect on his family, holes in police investigation (dog attack, eavesdropping, bias toward an attractive blond, etc.)?

[MorganSercu]

@Dee-Vee

the behavior of the defendants when he spoke with them at the police station seem subjective?

Maybe it was recorded by the police station?

[Mersidoats]

@eggbutt Thanks for posting. This is illuminating. I still want to know what started this whole chain of events off. What exactly did Barisone do (or not do?) that precipitated this whole event?

From my own experience in calling the NYPD during a hostile roommate situation, they were very reluctant to get involved beyond letting me make a police report about her behavior. Unless she physically harmed me, they couldn’t do anything beyond recommend that I initiate eviction proceedings. It was very frustrating. I lawyered up after that, moved my animals, removed all the furniture (including lightbulbs) from the common area, and she left within a month. That was lower stakes than this situation, though.

[MHM]

@Mersidoats

removed all the furniture (including lightbulbs) from the common area,

Props on the light bulbs! I would not have thought of that.

[Mersidoats]

@eggbutt

• Upon being informed of that circumstance, Kanarek’s father commenced
  threatening BARISONE with abusive legal process and litigation, for purposes of forcing
  BARISONE to permit Kanarek to live at the Farm, even temporarily as BARISONE’s house
  guest.
• Upon information and belief, Kanarek’s father did everything in his power to
  ensure that Kanarek and Goodwin would reside at the Farm (even temporarily) because Kanarek
  was banned from residing with her father and/or other immediate family in New Jersey due to
  Kanarek’s past history of violence, abuse, assault, drug use, psychotic behavior, and the like.

Well, this explains why she didn’t just go live at home while the house on the farm was repaired.

[trubandloki]

The quote below is line numbered 144 in the stuff that @eggbutt posted (thank you Eggbutt).
It explains the reference to LK’s age and appearance.

@eggbutt

Alternatively, during and throughout the aforementioned protracted, intentional,
derelict interactions which WASHINGTON TOWNSHIP and the DEFENDANT POLICE
OFFICERS had with BARISONE and Kanarek, WASHINGTON TOWNSHIP, the
DEFENDANT POLICE OFFICERS, and/or the other defendants, ignored, dismissed, hid, failed
to report, failed to acknowledge, failed to take seriously, and/or otherwise rejected, BARISONE
and/or his reports to them due to BARISONE’s advanced age (he was in his fifties), BARISONE’s
gender (he was a male reporting stalking and harassment by a female), BARISONE’s status as a
person who suffered from mental illness, and/or based upon other traits and characteristics
protected against unlawful discrimination under the New Jersey Law Against Discrimination (the
“LAD”).

[SillyHorse]

Another WOW here. Thanks, @eggbutt.

[clanter]

@eggbutt

• The placement of those devices without consent of the property owner, upon
  information and belief, is criminal trespassing under New Jersey law.
• The Eavesdropping was unlawful under New Jersey law.
• Moreover, the disclosure of unlawfully intercepted oral communications is a crime
  under New Jersey law.

if these recording were found there could be evidence of how the situation spiraled into insanity

[MorganSercu]

It’s not like Kanarek can deny their existence. Sounds like they were illegally placed so that is a problem in and of itself.

Standard disclaimer: She shouldn’t have been shot.

[eggbutt]

Or when she was released from the hospital.

[Marla_100]

you asked what did MB do or not do that precipitated the whole event-

My take is that MB was in a tight spot financially when LK came upon the scene looking for board and training. She had 5 horses to bring in so not a small amount of income.
MB had a pending insurance settlement due to pay off and after taking in LK, things around the barn with others deteriorated, MB and other barnmates wanted lK to leave so when the insurance payout came in, MB stopped training her horses.
she may have even put money up in advance to help him financially.
My speculation only.

[MHM]

@Marla_100

My take is that MB was in a tight spot financially when LK came upon the scene looking for board and training. She had 5 horses to bring in so not a small amount of income.

Realistically, most people in the horse business would be glad to have a new paying customer appear with five horses, regardless of their current financial situation. Without a crystal ball handy, he probably thought that was a great day at the time.

[Sdel]

@Dee-Vee

Or is this just a piece to set the stage for the trials…in other words establish certain proof points of his mental state, behavior of LK, effect on his family, holes in police investigation (dog attack, eavesdropping, bias toward an attractive blond, etc.)?

My understanding is that the initial claims just set the stage. They can be a bit clunky…

The big takeaway…this is the defense he’s going to take at the criminal trial… He had better hope that the mental incompetence sticks because they didn’t give themselves another out. By claiming he has no memory of the incident they have very little room to counter LK/RG’s story of what happened.

[clanter]

@MorganSercu

It’s not like Kanarek can deny their existence. Sounds like they were illegally placed so that is a problem in and of itself.

well the poster who said she was her admitted with great joy and gleam of installing the devices… several posters warned that this was illegal in New Jersey

But the recordings if found can be a two edged sword proving more than she wanted

[Mersidoats]

@eggbutt

• WASHINGTON TOWNSHIP issued orders that various living spaces occupied
  on the Farm were ordered to be vacated immediately until further notice, and that WASHINGTON
  TOWNSHIP would return later in the day to confirm whether BARISONE, Grey, Kanarek and
  Goodwin had, in fact, vacated the buildings.
• Having issued such an order, it was the duty and obligation of WASHINGTON
  TOWNSHIP to force Kanarek and Goodwin to vacate the Farm house; but when BARISONE
  requested that WASHINGTON TOWNSHIP do just that, WASHINGTON TOWNSHIP refused
  and directed BARISONE that it was his obligation to physically eject them. BARISONE advised
  MRS-L-001562-21 07/15/2021 1:56:46 PM Pg 24 of 36 Trans ID: LCV20211664981
  25
  WASHINGTON TOWNSHIP at that time, once again, that he was in fear for his life from
  violence threatened against him by Kanarek and Goodwin, which WASHINGTON TOWNSHIP
  again ignored intentionally.

This is also interesting. The township issues an order to vacate, but cannot enforce the order? Can someone weigh in on this?

[eggbutt]

I might be wrong but I believe when she started with MB she brought 1 horse. Then another, then bought one of MB’s horses. It sure doesn’t sound like he thought she was a gold mine any more than any of the other boarders he had at the time. Keep in mind she wasn’t the only person who had horses in training there!

Most of what LK has stated in these threads should be taken with a grain of salt at this point as many have learned from her messaging fiasco.

[LilRanger]

Idon’t know enough procedure, but his claim that the police consistently interviewed the alleged perpetrator before the reporting victim constitutes a beach of duty, does that have basis in anything?

It sounds reasonable to make contact with the victim so the perp can’t “fix” things. Or interview each simultaneously in different places.

[Jealoushe]

Seems to be setting the stage for insanity defense…which if MB was abused at as a child…ooof. That is really heartbreaking.

I watched a video on YouTube that had all the 911 calls from both sides, and my thought the whole time was wow…the cops literally let this drama fire slow burn until someone got shot. I agree the police did not do a good enough job handling these situations.