Filed today (Part 1)
M01014
Christopher L. Deininger, Esq., N.J. Bar ID No. 004271996
DEININGER & ASSOCIATES, LLP
415 Route 10, Suite 1
Randolph, New Jersey 07869
(973) 879-1610; Fax (973) 361-1241
Attorneys for Plaintiff
MICHAEL L. BARISONE,
Plaintiff,
v.
WASHINGTON TOWNSHIP in Morris
County, New Jersey; POLICE OFFICER
BRIAN SZYMANSKI; POLICE
OFFICER DEREK HEYMER; POLICE
OFFICER BRIAN BIGHAM; POLICE
OFFICER MICHAEL HADE; POLICE
OFFICER PHILIP SEABECK; POLICE
OFFICER THOMAS FALLENI;
POLICE OFFICER ANDREW TESORI;
POLICE OFFICER JASON HENSLEY;
POLICE OFFICER MICHAEL
THOMPSON; POLICE OFFICER
ANTHONY COSTANTINO; POLICE
OFFICER ROGER GARRISON; JOHN
& JANE DOE 1-20, & ABC COMPANY
1-20,
Defendants.
SUPERIOR COURT
OF NEW JERSEY
LAW DIVISION – MORRIS
COUNTY
DOCKET NO.: MRS-L-______-21
COMPLAINT WITH JURY
DEMAND
Plaintiff MICHAEL L. BARISONE (“Plaintiff” and/or “BARISONE”), by and through his
attorneys DEININGER & ASSOCIATES, LLP, as and for his Complaint against the defendants,
makes the following allegations:
THE PARTIES & OTHER ACTORS
- BARISONE is a 57-year-old Caucasian male who, at all times relevant hereto, had
an established career as a top, Olympic trainer of horses and riders in the equestrian sport of
dressage.
MRS-L-001562-21 07/15/2021 1:56:46 PM Pg 1 of 36 Trans ID: LCV20211664981
2 - At all times relevant hereto, BARISONE co-owned a farm located at 411 West
Mill Road, Long Valley, New Jersey (the “Farm”), where BARISONE built and operated an
Olympic-level, dressage horse farm and training facility, and thriving business. - At all times relevant hereto, the Farm had various visitors and/or occupants
including but not limited to: (a) BARISONE and his partner Mary Haskins Gray (“Gray”),
together with Gray’s minor children (the “children”); (b) Lauren S. Kanarek (“Kanarek”) and her
boyfriend Robert G. Goodwin (“Goodwin”); © Ruth Cox (“Cox”); (d) Justin Hardin (“Hardin”),
a long-term employee of BARISONE working and living at the Farm; and (e) numerous other
persons who worked at the Farm, trained at the Farm, boarded horses at the Farm, and/or otherwise
visited or occupied the premises. - Defendant WASHINGTON TOWNSHIP (“WASHINGTON TOWNSHIP”), is a
municipality located in Morris County, New Jersey, where it operates, oversees, and/or manages
various municipal services provided to its residents, including but not limited to public safety
services provided by the Washington Township Police Department, located at 1 East Springtown
Road, Long Valley, New Jersey 07853 (the “POLICE DEPARTMENT”); ambulance and
associated medical services provided by a volunteer ambulance/EMT squad; and other services. - At all times relevant hereto, the following defendant-persons were members of the
POLICE DEPARTMENT of WASHINGTON TOWNSHIP: (a) DEFENDANT POLICE
OFFICER BRIAN SZYMANSKI (“SZYMANSKI”); (b) DEFENDANT POLICE OFFICER
DEREK HEYMER (“HEYMER”); © DEFENDANT POLICE OFFICER BRIAN BIGHAM
(“BIGHAM”); (d) DEFENDANT POLICE OFFICER MICHAEL HADE (“HADE”); (e)
DEFENDANT POLICE OFFICER PHILIP SEABECK (“SEABECK”); (f) DEFENDANT
POLICE OFFICER THOMAS FALLENI (“FALLENI”); (g) DEFENDANT POLICE OFFICER
MRS-L-001562-21 07/15/2021 1:56:46 PM Pg 2 of 36 Trans ID: LCV20211664981
3
ANDREW TESORI (“TESORI”); (h) DEFENDANT POLICE OFFICER JASON HENSLEY
(“HENSLEY”); (i) DEFENDANT POLICE OFFICER MICHAEL THOMPSON
(“THOMPSON”); (j) DEFENDANT POLICE OFFICER ANTHONY COSTANTINO
(“COSTANTINO”); and (k) DEFENDANT POLICE OFFICER ROGER GARRISON
(“GARRISON”). For purposes of this pleading, BARISONE may reference those persons
collectively as the “POLICE OFFICER DEFENDANTS.” - Upon information and belief, at all times relevant hereto, each and every one of
the POLICE OFFICER DEFENDANTS lived, resided, and/or worked in Morris County, New
Jersey. - Now and at all times relevant hereto, fictitiously named defendants JOHN DOE &
JANE DOE 1 through 20 are persons presently unknown who, individually, and/or in concert with
the other defendants and/or other actors named here, and/or acting under the direction and control
of one or more of the other defendants or actors named here, committed acts and omissions
connected with injury and resulting damages caused to BARISONE. - Now and at all times relevant hereto, fictitiously named other defendants ABC
COMPANY 1 through 20 corporations, partnerships, limited liability companies, and/or other
types of entities, presently unknown which, individually, and/or in concert with the other
defendants and/or actors named here, and/or acting under the direction and control of one or more
of the other defendants or actors named here, committed acts and omissions connected with injury
and resulting damages caused to BARISONE.
ALLEGATIONS & CLAIMS - Commencing in or about the late 1990s, BARISONE became co-owner of the
Farm and started transforming the property into a world-class training facility for dressage.
MRS-L-001562-21 07/15/2021 1:56:46 PM Pg 3 of 36 Trans ID: LCV20211664981
4 - Himself a one time, highly competitive dressage rider who had grown up in
Upstate New York where he started riding at an early age, BARISONE had gravitated towards
training riders and horses in dressage, investing years of time, training and effort to become one
of the sport’s leading trainers. - BARISONE’s career reached a milestone when, at the 2016 Olympics held in
Brazil, multiple competitors trained and/or coach by BARISONE won medals in the competitions.
BARISONE operated a thriving business through which he trained riders and/or horses, raised
horses, and/or boarded horse. - People interested in excelling in the sport of dressage sought out BARISONE to
become their trainer, boarding their horses at the Farm (including certain horses valued in excess
of $500,000), and coming there to train with BARISONE and his business in his world-class
dressage barn with an adjoining club room, office, locker room, and other facilities. - The Farm included as well a farm house, which was a single-family residence
divided into two living spaces under one roof with shared spaces and facilities, such as hallways,
entrances, porches, and the like. - While the farm house could be characterized as having two living spaces, the fact
was that the farm house constituted a single domicile, with its residents living like a single
household. - The physical layout of the Farm included frontage on West Mill Road, with the
farm house about 400 feet back from the road, and the dressage barn and training facility another
1,600-1,700 feet up an unlit driveway behind the farm house. - Commencing in or about March 2018, Kanarek sought to become a pupil of
BARISONE for purposes of training in dressage.
MRS-L-001562-21 07/15/2021 1:56:46 PM Pg 4 of 36 Trans ID: LCV20211664981
5 - With her parents’ financial support, Kanarek wanted to train with BARISONE and
board her horse at the Farm during the summer season which covers (essentially) the months of
April through September, following which (during the winter season) Kanarek would return to
the Carolinas where she lived with her boyfriend Goodwin and boarded her horse(s). - Kanarek’s aspirational goal, upon information and belief, was to “train for the
Olympics” and become a “world class” dressage rider, though the reality seemed more likely to
be that Kanarek would remain an amateur who enjoyed the sport and the personal satisfaction one
has when they take lessons and improve in a pursuit they love. - At that time Kanarek presented as an attractive, blond woman in her mid- to late
30’s, with acceptable horseback riding skills, an acceptable horse, and what appeared to be nearly
limitless financial support and backing of her father, a wealthy attorney from Livingston, New
Jersey. - But there was an exceptionally dark and disturbing reality concerning Kanarek that
was being hidden from view by Kanarek and her parents. - Unbeknownst the BARISONE, Kanarek had a history of domestic conflict
following which she was banished from residing with her family. - Unbeknownst to BARISONE, Kanarek was a former heroin addict with a lengthy
criminal history, including criminal assault. - Unbeknownst to BARISONE, Kanarek’s background included criminal
harassment and stalking, including harassment that involved extensive use of the Internet and/or
social media to make veiled and direct threats of injury, mayhem, violence, and criminal acts
against persons with whom she was having interpersonal conflict.
MRS-L-001562-21 07/15/2021 1:56:46 PM Pg 5 of 36 Trans ID: LCV20211664981
6 - Unbeknownst to BARISONE, Kanarek’s tactics in the past included making false
reports and false statements against people she perceived to be her “enemy,” to child-protectiveservices agencies and/or other governmental agencies, including the police. - Unbeknownst to BARISONE, Kanarek’s past included owning firearms and at
least one incident of discharging her firearm, out of anger and rage, at other people and/or their
personal property. - Unbeknownst the BARISONE, Safesport, the organization which purports to
protect people from abuse and harassment within the pursuit of sports, had multiple complaints
about Kanarek from persons Kanarek had harassed, stalked, and/or otherwise endeavored to
“destroy.” - Unbeknownst the BARISONE, Kanarek’s boyfriend Goodwin had an equally
disturbing past which included but was not limited to: drug addiction and heroin abuse; violence;
criminal conduct; stalking; harassment; and the like. - But for BARISONE’s lack of knowledge of Kanarek’s hidden background,
BARISONE would not have agreed to become her dressage trainer; would not have agreed to
permit Kanarek’s horse(s) to board at the Farm; and/or would not have engaged in any other form
of relationship with Kanarek as coach, trainer, house guest, or otherwise. - Similarly, but for BARISONE’s lack of knowledge of Goodwin’s hidden
background, BARISONE would not have agreed to permit Kanarek to bring Goodwin to the Farm
as her boyfriend and/or in any other capacity Kanarek and Goodwin might have proffered. - BARISONE himself has a medical history which includes psychological trauma
from abuse as a child.
MRS-L-001562-21 07/15/2021 1:56:46 PM Pg 6 of 36 Trans ID: LCV20211664981
7 - At all times relevant hereto, BARISONE had been in treatment and/or counseling
for his past trauma and status as a victim of child abuse and resulting trauma. - In that regard, BARISONE was an “egg shell” victim of future trauma who was
vulnerable and susceptible to sustaining injury from harassment, stalking, verbal assault, and
threats of violence from persons like Kanarek and/or Goodwin. - At all times relevant hereto, BARISONE displayed the traits, characteristics and
affect of a person having psychological vulnerability and potential victimization from abuse, in
need of protection from the police under circumstances indicating a basis for being in fear of
injury, harm, violence, and/or threats of same. - Commencing in or about May 2019, Kanarek and Goodwin became temporary
house guests of BARISONE in the farm house at the Farm. - BARISONE had told Kanarek that she could not become a tenant at the Farm due
to water damage to the farm house which made it unlivable. - Upon being informed of that circumstance, Kanarek’s father commenced
threatening BARISONE with abusive legal process and litigation, for purposes of forcing
BARISONE to permit Kanarek to live at the Farm, even temporarily as BARISONE’s house
guest. - Upon information and belief, Kanarek’s father did everything in his power to
ensure that Kanarek and Goodwin would reside at the Farm (even temporarily) because Kanarek
was banned from residing with her father and/or other immediate family in New Jersey due to
Kanarek’s past history of violence, abuse, assault, drug use, psychotic behavior, and the like. - Separate and apart from that temporary “house guest” arrangement, Kanarek was
MRS-L-001562-21 07/15/2021 1:56:46 PM Pg 7 of 36 Trans ID: LCV20211664981
8
again boarding her horse in the barn at the Farm. - Soon after she started stay as a house guest at the Farm, Kanarek commenced
displaying behavior towards BARISONE and/or Gray which was increasingly threatening and/or
otherwise unacceptable. - Kanarek’s behavior included an upward spiral of harassment and stalking of
BARISONE, Gray, and/or Gray’s children, both on the Internet and throughout social media like
Facebook, where Kanarek made veiled and direct threats against them of ever-increasing severity. - As the situation escalated, BARISONE commenced uncovering the highly
problematic and threatening criminal and social backgrounds of Kanarek and Goodwin. - It was in or about June 2019, for example, that BARISONE learned of Kanarek’s
status as a drug addict, criminal, and person with a history of harassment, stalking, threats of
violence, and violent assault, against others. - BARISONE and Gray began to observe, find, and/or otherwise become aware of
Internet postings by Kanarek, in which Kanarek threatened harm, injury and/or violence against
BARISONE, Gray, Gray’s minor children living at the Farm, and/or horses boarding in the barn. - As of July 31, 2019, and at all relevant times thereafter, BARISONE’s affect,
statements and behaviors evidenced, outwardly, that BARISONE was being psychologically
assaulted and victimized by Kanarek and Goodwin, such that the defendants knew, intentionally
disregarded and/or recklessly disregarded, BARISONE’s mounting psychological distress and
potential psychiatric breakdown that could occur unless appropriate and sufficient action was
taken by the defendants to intervene.
The July 31, 2019 Incident
MRS-L-001562-21 07/15/2021 1:56:46 PM Pg 8 of 36 Trans ID: LCV20211664981
9 - The situation continued to escalate, out of control, with Kanarek increasing her
terroristic threats, harassment, stalking, and/or other criminal behaviors until the night of July 31,
2019, when BARISONE made his first “911” call to the WASHINGTON TOWNSHIP POLICE
DEPARTMENT seeking emergency assistance. - On July 31, 2019, at approximately 20:00 hours, BARISONE called “911” and
reported that he had been assaulted verbally by Kanarek and/or Goodwin; that he and others at
the Farm were being subjected to other criminal behaviors by Kanarek and/or Goodwin, including
but not limited to behaviors which constituted unlawful criminal threats, harassment, cyber
stalking, and cyber harassment; their fear; and other relevant information. - Thereafter, DEFENDANT TESORI and DEFENDANT SEABECK arrived at the
Farm, whereupon BARISONE and/or others repeated their reports to WASHINGTON
TOWNSHIP that there had been a verbal assault by Kanarek and/or Goodwin; that BARISONE
and others at the Farm were being subjected to other criminal behaviors by Kanarek and/or
Goodwin including but not limited to behaviors which constituted unlawful criminal threats,
harassment, cyber stalking, and cyber harassment; and that BARISONE and others were in fear
of immediate danger and injury to their physical health, wellbeing and/or the wellbeing of their
property. - DEFENDANT TESORI and DEFENDANT SEABECK intentionally disregarded
the facts and circumstances being reported to them and intentionally failed to act to protect
BARISONE and/or the others making the report to WASHINGTON TOWNSHIP against
Kanarek and Goodwin. - For example, during the July 31, 2019 incident, BARISONE’s affect, statements
and behaviors evidencing, outwardly, that BARISONE was being psychologically assaulted and
MRS-L-001562-21 07/15/2021 1:56:46 PM Pg 9 of 36 Trans ID: LCV20211664981
10
victimized by Kanarek and Goodwin, such that the police knew, intentionally disregarded and/or
recklessly disregarded, BARISONE’s mounting psychological distress and potential psychiatric
breakdown that could occur unless appropriate and sufficient action was taken by the defendants
to intervene in the developing criminal dispute. - Thereafter, DEFENDANT TESORI and DEFENDANT SEABECK intentionally
authored and issued a Washington Twp Police Department Investigation Report that was
materially false and misleading (the “August 1, 2019 Police Report”). - The August 1, 2019 Police Report was materially false and misleading in that the
report, inter alia: (a) failed to document the complaint by BARISONE and the others that some of
them were in fear of immediate danger and injury to their physical health, wellbeing and/or the
wellbeing of their property; and/or (b) failed to document other facts and circumstances necessary
to accurately and effectively convey the true circumstances and resulting material threat of injury,
harm, and/or other mayhem occurring at the Farm that day.
The August 1, 2019 Incident - The situation continued to escalate, out of control, with Kanarek increasing her
terroristic threats, harassment, stalking, and/or other criminal behaviors, causing BARISONE to
make his second “911” call to the WASHINGTON TOWNSHIP POLICE DEPARTMENT
seeking emergency assistance. - On August 1, 2019, at approximately 18:00 hours, BARISONE called “911” and
again reported that he had been assaulted verbally by Kanarek and/or Goodwin; that he and others
at the Farm were being subjected to other criminal behaviors by Kanarek and/or Goodwin,
including but not limited to behaviors which constituted unlawful criminal threats, harassment,
cyber stalking, and cyber harassment; their fear; and other relevant information.
MRS-L-001562-21 07/15/2021 1:56:46 PM Pg 10 of 36 Trans ID: LCV20211664981
11 - Thereafter, DEFENDANT HENSLEY and DEFENDANT SEABECK arrived at
the Farm and, upon information and belief, in abject violation of standard police protocol, policy
and procedure, interviewed Kanarek and Goodwin before the DEFENDANT POLICE
OFFICERS interviewed BARISONE, the criminal complainant who called “911.” - When DEFENDANT HENSLEY and DEFENDANT SEABECK finally did
interview BARISONE and/or the others being threatened by Kanarek and/or Goodwin,
BARISONE and/or others reported to WASHINGTON TOWNSHIP that there had been a verbal
assault by Kanarek and/or Goodwin; that BARISONE and others at the Farm were being subjected
to other criminal behaviors by Kanarek and/or Goodwin including but not limited to behaviors
which constituted unlawful criminal threats, harassment, cyber stalking, and cyber harassment;
and that BARISONE and others were in fear for their lives and in fear of immediate danger and
injury to their physical health and wellbeing, and/or to the wellbeing of their property. - DEFENDANT HENSLEY and DEFENDANT SEABECK intentionally
disregarded the facts and circumstances being reported to them and intentionally failed to take
appropriate action choosing instead to avoid their duty to act by falsely characterizing the situation
as a “private dispute,” a tactic those defendants, the other defendants, and particularly defendant
WASHINGTON TOWNSHIP, utilized unlawfully as a practice, custom, and/or unofficial policy. - For example, during the August 1, 2019 incident, BARISONE’s affect,
statements, and behaviors evidencing, outwardly, that BARISONE was being psychologically
assaulted and victimized by Kanarek and Goodwin, such that the police knew, intentionally
disregarded, and/or recklessly disregarded BARISONE’s mounting psychological distress and
likely psychiatric breakdown that was going to occur unless appropriate and sufficient action was
taken by the defendants to intervene in what was obviously a police matter and not a “private
MRS-L-001562-21 07/15/2021 1:56:46 PM Pg 11 of 36 Trans ID: LCV20211664981
12
dispute.” - Thereafter, DEFENDANT HENSLEY and DEFENDANT SEABECK
intentionally authored and issued a Washington Twp Police Department Investigation Report that
was materially false and misleading (the “August 2, 2019 Police Report”). - The August 2, 2019 Police Report was materially false and misleading in that the
report, inter alia: (a) failed to document the complaints by BARISONE and the others that they
were in fear for their lives and/or in fear of immediate danger and injury to their physical health
and wellbeing, and/or to the wellbeing of their property; and/or (b) failed to document other facts
and circumstances necessary to accurately and effectively convey the true circumstances and
resulting material threat of injury, harm, and/or other mayhem occurring at the Farm that day. - In connection with their responds to BARISONE’s August 1, 2019 “911” call and
their visit to the Farm, DEFENDANT SEABECK contacted a Morris County Assistant Prosecutor
for purposes of discussing the August 1, 2019 incident with the Morris County Prosecutor’s Office
(“MCPO”). - During that call with MCPO, DEFENDANT SEABECK failed intentionally to
make a truthful and/or accurate report of the August 1, 2019 incident at the Farm, which
inaccuracies included, but were not limited to, the failure of WASHINGTON TOWNSHIP to
report that BARISONE and others had expressed that they were in fear for their lives and/or in
fear of immediate danger and injury to their physical health and wellbeing, and/or to the wellbeing
of their property, from harm threatened by Kanarek and/or Goodwin. - Upon information and belief, the intentional inaccurate reporting of the August 1,
2019 incident was part of a practice, custom and policy adopted by WASHINGTON TOWNSHIP
to endeavor to limit police involvement by falsely characterizing as “civil matters” and/or “private
MRS-L-001562-21 07/15/2021 1:56:46 PM Pg 12 of 36 Trans ID: LCV20211664981
13
disputes” incidents which, in fact, were criminal in nature. - There are other residents of WASHINGTON TOWNSHIP who have been
subjected to the same illegal and unlawful treatment by WASHINGTON TOWNSHIP and its
POLICE DEPARTMENT.
The August 3, 2019 Incident - The situation continued to escalate, out of control, with Kanarek increasing her
terroristic threats, harassment, stalking, and/or other criminal behaviors, causing BARISONE to
make his third “911” call to the WASHINGTON TOWNSHIP POLICE DEPARTMENT seeking
emergency assistance. - On August 3, 2019, at approximately 9:00 hours, BARISONE called “911” and
again reported that he and others at the Farm were being assaulted verbally by Kanarek and/or
Goodwin; that he and others at the Farm were being subjected to other criminal behaviors by
Kanarek and/or Goodwin, including but not limited to behaviors which constituted unlawful
criminal threats, harassment, cyber stalking, and cyber harassment; their fear; and other relevant
information. - Thereafter, DEFENDANT THOMPSON and DEFENDANT FALLENI arrived at
the Farm and, upon information and belief, in abject violation of standard police protocol, policy
and procedure, interviewed Kanarek and Goodwin before the DEFENDANT POLICE
OFFICERS interviewed BARISONE, the criminal complainant who called “911.” - When DEFENDANT THOMPSON and DEFENDANT FALLENI finally did
interview BARISONE and/or the others being threatened by Kanarek and/or Goodwin,
BARISONE and/or others reported to WASHINGTON TOWNSHIP that there had been a verbal
assault by Kanarek and/or Goodwin; that BARISONE and others at the Farm were being subjected
MRS-L-001562-21 07/15/2021 1:56:46 PM Pg 13 of 36 Trans ID: LCV20211664981
14
to other criminal behaviors by Kanarek and/or Goodwin including but not limited to behaviors
which constituted unlawful criminal threats, harassment, cyber stalking, and cyber harassment;
and that BARISONE and others were in fear for their lives and in fear of immediate danger and
injury to their physical health and wellbeing, and/or to the wellbeing of their property. - For example, BARISONE and/or the other victims reported expressly to the
responding POLICE OFFICER DEFENDANTS a number of material, salient facts which they
chose intentionally to disregard, including the following:
(a) Kanarek was believed to have possession of, and/or current access to, a loaded
firearm;
(b) Kanarek had a history of threatening to discharge and/or actually discharging her
loaded firearm at people and property for the purpose of causing harm, injury
and/or damage;
© Kanarek threatened BARSIONE and others that Kanarek was coming to attack
them with “weapons hot,” meaning that she was armed and ready to discharge a
firearm at one or more of them;
(d) Kanarek was making threats of harm, physical harm, violence, and/or mayhem
against BARISONE, Gray, and/or others, in writing, on the Internet through
social media posting which were and/or could be made available for the
DEFENDANT POLICE OFFICERS to see; and/or,
(e) Kanarek had a criminal history, history as a drug addict, and other personal
history demonstrating that Kanarek was a clear, immediate, and present danger
to BARISONE, Gray, Gray’s children, others at the Farm, and/or horses being
boarded at the Farm.
MRS-L-001562-21 07/15/2021 1:56:46 PM Pg 14 of 36 Trans ID: LCV20211664981
15 - During the August 3, 2019 Incident, Kanarek and/or Goodwin expressly told the
responding DEFENDANT POLICE OFFICERS that Kanarek/Goodwin had place electronic
devices on the premises, permitting Kanarek and Goodwin to intercept and thereafter disclose
private oral communications BARISONE, Gray, and/or others were having at the Farm
(hereinafter, the “Eavesdropping”). - The placement of those devices without consent of the property owner, upon
information and belief, is criminal trespassing under New Jersey law. - The Eavesdropping was unlawful under New Jersey law.
- Moreover, the disclosure of unlawfully intercepted oral communications is a crime
under New Jersey law. - Nevertheless, the responding DEFENDANT POLICE OFFICERS failed to
investigate the criminal acts Goodwin has reported to them he had been committing, failed to take
other appropriate non-discretionary action in response to notification that such criminal conduct
was occurring, and intentionally failed to intervene. - DEFENDANT THOMPSON and DEFENDANT FALLENI intentionally
disregarded all of those facts and circumstances being reported to them and intentionally failed to
act to intervene in what obviously was a police matter and not just a “private dispute.” - Those POLICE OFFICER DEFENDANTS also disregarded, during the August 3,
2019 incident, BARISONE’s affect, statements, and behaviors evidencing, outwardly, that
BARISONE was being psychologically assaulted and victimized by Kanarek and Goodwin, such
that the police knew, intentionally disregarded, and/or recklessly disregarded BARISONE’s
mounting psychological distress and likely psychiatric breakdown about to occur unless
appropriate and sufficient action was taken by the defendants to intervene.
MRS-L-001562-21 07/15/2021 1:56:46 PM Pg 15 of 36 Trans ID: LCV20211664981
16 - Thereafter, DEFENDANT THOMPSON and DEFENDANT FALLENI
intentionally authored and issued a Washington Twp Police Department Investigation Report that
was materially false and misleading (the “August 8, 2019 Police Report”). - The August 8, 2019 Police Report was materially false and misleading in that the
report, inter alia: (a) failed to document the complaint by BARISONE and the others that some of
them were in fear for their lives and in fear of immediate danger and injury to their physical health
and wellbeing, and/or the wellbeing of their property; (b) failed to document the facts and
circumstances concerning Kanarek’s actual or potential possession of a firearm, and her threats
to use the firearm against BARISONE and others by coming for them with “weapons hot”; and/or
© failed to document other facts and circumstances necessary to accurately and effectively
convey the true circumstances and resulting material threat of injury, harm, and/or other mayhem
occurring at the Farm that day. - In connection with their responds to BARISONE’s August 3, 2019 “911” call and
their visit to the Farm, the responding DEFENDANT POLICE OFFICERS failed to contact the
MCPO and/or any of its assistant prosecutors for purposes of discussing the August 3, 2019
incident and/or reporting to the MCPO the escalating, increasingly dangerous situation at the
Farm. - Upon information and belief, the intentional inaccurate reporting of the August 3,
2019 incident was another example of the practice, custom and policy adopted by
WASHINGTON TOWNSHIP to endeavor to limit police involvement by falsely characterizing
as “civil matters” and/or “private disputes” incidents which, in fact, were criminal in nature. - Upon information and belief, had the defendants (especially the responding
DEFENDANT POLICE OFFICERS) acted appropriately in response to BARISONE’s criminal
MRS-L-001562-21 07/15/2021 1:56:46 PM Pg 16 of 36 Trans ID: LCV20211664981
17
complaint and “911” emergency call on August 3, 2019, the defendants would have discovered
that in the early morning hours on or about August 3, 2019, Goodwin was conducting Internet
searches in an effort to find address information for the location where Gray’s children were about
to be attending a family reunion; that Goodwin and Kanarek were stalking Gray’s children for
criminal, deviant and illegal purposes; and that there was probable cause to intervene in the
situation which was not a private dispute but, rather, a criminal matter.
The August 4, 2019 Incident - The situation continued to escalate, out of control, with Kanarek increasing her
terroristic threats, harassment, stalking, and/or other criminal behaviors, causing BARISONE to
make his fourth “911” call to the WASHINGTON TOWNSHIP POLICE DEPARTMENT
seeking emergency assistance.