BIG Kudos all the way around! Doesn’t the thread move so much more smoothly?!?
And I love the running total for donations to the GFM.
48 Likes
In both cases (the pleadings in the criminal case and the transcripts), it’s faster and easier to turn them over than to file motions that one shouldn’t have to turn them over.
Now, if it hurts your case to turn them over. you might well not take the fastest and easiest route.
Since MB’s prior mental health records were disclosed during the criminal trial and discussed in great detail in so far as Dienenger, the civil defense attorney, was setting the base for the civil trial while aiding the criminal defense attorney in the criminal defense, that suddenly they are protected by HiPAA after MB has been in treatment at a mental health facility with access to several trained and experienced mental health practitioners and possibly sent for medical tests does raise pertinent questions as to what can be affecting his mental health beyond what was brought out at the civil trial.
Dr Hassan’s testimony and description of his sessions with MB were sobering, Dr Simring’s as well, but Dr Hassan really dug into depths of possibilities of what was going on with MB and the long-standing nature and causes of the problems. It was the polar opposite of Dr Schlesinger’s testimony that MB was sane at the time.
Also, if the appeals claim can prove misbehavior on the part of the court as it pertained to the criminal trial and any following activity that could affect the civil trial, then that is relevant as well to the civil court and ongoing mediation.
1 Like
I so have to agree that the only reason Kirby Kanarek (@Seeker1) has not responded in any way to the subpoenas asking for the transcripts she has claimed to have is because those transcripts are going to hurt their case.
41 Likes
For all of claims to want to “tell their story” they sure are working hard on not telling it.
47 Likes
No donations to Michael Barisone’s Go Fund Me in 8 days.
2 Likes
True that.
11 Likes
Off topic, but Mr. B could have another potentially high profile case. This one actually has shovels and pick axes found in cars.
13 Likes
I agree.
And… there’s the whole potential for a SafeSport appeal at some point. My guess is the Kanareks want to make that process as painful, difficult and expensive for MB as they possibly can…
22 Likes
Oof. Good luck to him. That one sounds like it could be a challenge for any lawyer.
6 Likes
Stone has responded to the subponeas regarding the transcripts asking that the subponeas be quashed. We are waiting for judge to rule on that motion as well as the defense’s motion to compel.
Why on earth should KK turn over the transcripts prior to the judge ruling on those motions?
1 Like
I just kicked in my $10, which was of course due.
34 Likes
Why on earth should SGF turn over evidence prior to the judge ruling on motions requesting such evidence? 
(And I will double my contribution this month to the GFM.)
31 Likes
Isn’t Michael Barisone going to be deposed at some point? Can’t whomever is the Kanarek attorney at that time ask any questions they want at their expense?
Furthermore, doesn’t LK have to prove her case rather than demanding Barisone defend something she hasn’t submitted?
I have all the confidence in the world that Deininger, Bilinkas, and Stone have all their ducks in a row with oodles of evidence of LK/RG/JK terrorism, harassment, etc. But wait, has sweet Kirby Kanarek complied with the subpoena yet? If not, why hasn’t she been tossed in jail? Just like former POTUS, these people (for lack of a better unapproved noun) are not above the law. Hate it for them.
30 Likes
Requesting documents in the other party’s possession is what discovery is about.
If SGF has any documents that back up the alleged harassment incident, Stone is legitimately asking that the documents be disclosed. If no documentation on the alleged incident exists, their admitting no such documentation exists is useful to the plaintiff.
I think Stone is saying “Document the alleged harassment incident, or stop alleging it”.
Neither MBs lawyers nor SGFs lawyers have filed motions opposing Stones motion at this point.
2 Likes
I am here to give us all a big round of applause!
Keep up the great work!
49 Likes
I just donated in advance and for past indiscretions replying to posts that don’t deserve my time or brain cells. The brief quiet time between threads has allowed many of us to refocus on exactly what is important rather than being baited by ridiculousness.
45 Likes
I feel like a real adult……
18 Likes
Can anyone refresh my memory as to how Lollypop responded to one of the requests early on in discovery related to her turning over all her social media posts? Didn’t she tell MB’s side to just get them from the internet themselves, or something like that?
33 Likes
