I am amused by the posts I see here on this topic.
Because most of them are BS.
A little background.
I started riding in early 1941 and went on my first foxhunt Thanksgiving 1941.
During the ensuing years, I have spent a lot of time with rehabing bad horses. I have been bucked off, dragged, struck, kicked and have had a hell of a good time though it all.
Obviously at 81 well on the way to 82, I have slowed down some but I am at the present time rehabing an OTTB who just yesterday decided to jump about 4’ high over a 2’ jump and hit the ground bucking.
Luckily they were straight in line bucks and not the zig zag bucks or sunfish bucks so they were easy.
So I have been there and done that.
I have worn regular boxes for almost all of those years.
In the winter, I wear the Cabelos heavy silk long underwear.
In the summer, boxers.
I may ride in blue jeans with half chaps or in those abominable skin tight breeches that have been the fashion for the past 20 years or so and boots when hunting or riding with others.
How I wish I had kept those old full breeches of the long ago past.
During those years, I have tried at various times jock straps, jockey underwear, boxers sort of with tight legs, etc., and it is all the same.
The bottom line is that if you can ride and if you have the proper seat, it makes absolutely no difference what you wear.
Someone made the crack about “commando”. Never tried it but I would bet any amount of money that I could ride cross country with nothing on but half chaps and keep up with anyone.
Between winter time and horse fly season, anyway.
In all of those years, I doubt that there have been more than 3 “incidents”.
So it is like biting your lip. You curse and then go on with it.
But I can tell you I have bit my lip a thousand times for every “incident” while riding.
There are many many things about riding that will hurt you a hell of a lot more and a lot more often.
So this is a funny topic for the bar, but in real life has absolutely no impact (pardon the pun) on how we ride.
Again, that is only if you can ride and have developed a good seat. Obviously there is a learning curve and during that time there will be accidents of varying kinds. But smashing one’s testicles will not be in the list of first 100 things that can happen.
Blisters on those tender legs, sore butts, a few falls, a horse that figures out you are scared so he goes back to the barn, those are the things for the beginner to worry about.
CSSJR