I’m in agreement with others who’ve said the Shedrow horse clothing isn’t always the best quality or fit - with one exception in my experience: the traditional plaid sheet and blanket (Baker copies) are not bad quality at all and do hold up pretty decently. I had both real Bakers and the Shedrow copies - both weights - and some features of the Shedrow I actually prefer over the genuine Bakers.
I find the way the surcingles attach to the Shedrow sheet/blanket are in a better location and less likely to tear than the genuine Bakers. At least on my horses. Plus the Shedrows come with dees for leg straps and I use leg straps on every article of horse clothing that is meant to be worn unattended - period. (I have them added to the Horsewear Ireland items that I have and to the real Bakers. You actually can order Bakers from Curvon with the dees already attached but it costs extra.)
The fabric on the genuine Bakers is a bit tighter weave and slightly less likely to attract shavings than the Shedrows. The fit of the Bakers is really more “Thoroughbredy” - for a narrower horse - than the Shedrows. The Bakers tend not to fit heavier-built horses very well, while it seems that the Shedrows fit a little wider variety of equine builds.
I’ve found both brands to be durable when worn by geldings hell-bent on getting dirty when they are worn under turnout sheets/blankets but the fabric is not the best choice for this as it tends to be fairly abrasive on the coat.
Anything else “Shedrow” for horse clothing is usually an epic fail in the fit department for my horses! (Too small in the shoulders from front to rear and too long in length towards the tail. The drop is appropriate for the sizing.)
OP, I would skip the Palm Beach sheet as it’s very “plasticy” on the outside and anything with fleece on the inside is going to be a hair and shavings magnet and difficult to clean. I personally would go with the Baker/Shedrow blanket for some extra warmth or even the Bucas mentioned above.
Please help!