Just try reading this discussion from an outsider’s perspective. Yuk.
KAM - thank you for posting that from PH. SO true.
I also have watched Anky perform both years at Spruce, as well as the Celle stallions. I love watching Anky and will applaud her style and accomplishments till the cows come home.
The Celle stallions put on a fabulous show also… But my opinion was that it was A SHOW - a demonstration and a good one at that, but it was not the highest level of dressage.
Those matched chestnut stallions are all wearing matching tack, with highly polished gold breastcollars & other fancy trimmings. Then there are the motionless riders with their long red coats and big hats. Their turnout is flashy and flawless, and their timing in their riding superb. They did the “tricks” that got oohs and aahs from the crowd, and from what I remember, for me it wasn’t the most amazing performance ever. If you took away all the glitz and glamour attached to the Celle show and put just one chestnut horse in the ring with a rider in a top hat and tails, it would have lacked sparkle and energy. Sure you would have seen a beautiful rider on a horse with a big trot and great movement, but the really collected GP movements… just not what I saw with Anky on her horses.
Her horses were working very hard, but still made it look easy 95% of the time. And my thought is that sometimes all the movements still aren’t so confirmed in the horses she brings over on the long trip to Canada to do a demo. You could tell that Junior’s piaff needed work - it’s not automatic for him.
<BLOCKQUOTE class=“ip-ubbcode-quote”><font size="-1">quote:</font><HR> These hanoverians were soft and flexible their ears were forward (or to the side,but never back!), and their movement… WOW. I’ve YET to see any dressage horse that compares to those Hanoverians with movement, grace and style… It was as though they were floating a good foot off the ground - and they were quiet and relaxed amidst all the distractions. <HR></BLOCKQUOTE>
Hmm… If you were there for the DuMaurier, you must have been so taken by all the big trots that you missed the one saucy stallion who was so full of himself that he broke his breastcollar? His ears were NOT always forward, and he thought the “distractions” of the crowd were just reason for him to be extra fancy! He was absolutely my favorite boy out there because he was full of personality, where some of the other studs looked like robots.
All the top riders are only human. We can chose to learn from them, or criticize them without really understanding what we’ve seen. Like I said before, I will applaud Anky always, but that doesn’t mean I don’t see some mistakes in her performance. I don’t think she’s perfect. But I know that if it were me in that big ring riding for 50,000 people I’d make a lot more mistakes than that!! I’d give anything to be 1/2 as good as she is. Just my 2 cents.