I’m late to this thread, but WOW. Nail on head. You can tell so much about someone by how they load a horse on a trailer.
It’s why I almost always politely decline help loading my mare. We’ve calmly practiced trailer loading very extensively (I can proudly say she now self-loads), and if she needs an extra moment to assess or understand what I’m asking of her, I’m cool with that. I can wait. The last thing I need is the added pressure of someone “helping” – because in my experience, that help usually manifests as physically pushing or aggressively driving the horse into the trailer – with that sudden urgency and bad energy that said “assistance” brings. No thanks!
Related but totally unnecessary story:
I once took my mare to a retail store in town for some training (yes, you read that right!) so we could get her used to automatic sliding doors before taking her to a nursing home for a visit. I still remember trying to load her back on the trailer when we were done, in the middle of a parking lot next to a main road.
She. Would. Not. Get. Back. In.
Knowing I was on full display and not wanting any random member of the public to assume she was being abused if I got tough with her, I decided to play the slow game. Circling, letting her sniff the ramp, etc. Eventually that devolved into me just pulling on her face. I remember eventually calling my husband in tears of embarrassment and frustration, hoping he’d have some clever idea to get her in (he didn’t, but was very sympathetic). At one point, I was pulling so hard that the snap on the lead shank suddenly popped off her halter (?!) and she was just standing there, loose, in the parking lot. (“Don’t panic, don’t panic, don’t panic… just caaaalmly grab her halter”.)
In the end, I finally got her on by swinging my left leg around me as I led her forward to gently bop her on the bum with the toe of my boot. A car pulled up with two women inside, and one leaned out the window to admit they’d watched me struggling (awwwwkward). They said they were so impressed with how patient I’d been! Oh my, if they only knew
(Also, someone’s always watching.)
Since that episode, I’ve kept a dressage whip in the trailer just as an extra back-up aid so we never have to go through that again. Just a gentle tap-tap on her bum asks her to walk forward, no drama, if she “forgets” how to self-load.