What looks like Laminitis, but isn't?

What seems like laminitis, but isn’t? Or what causes laminitis when it seems like there’s no typical cause?

I have four years of history with this horse and have worked with numerous vets and even done a trip to a university vet school for further testing. So I do have a lot of input already on what it’s not, and can answer lots of questions you might throw at me. But I’m deliberately not including details up front, because I’m looking for new perspectives, fresh eyes on the case.

The 9 year old clydesdale gelding will seem to be fine one day, and within 24 hours be reduced to walking like he’s got hobbles on. Tiny little ouchy steps, slight rocking back on haunches. No discernable heat in hooves. Digital pulse hard to find, but FEATHERS. No change in diet. Did not suddenly get larger quantity of grain or grass.

Day 1 of soreness will seem like right foot is much worse than left, day 2 of soreness will seem like left foot is much worse than right. Day 3 I’ll give up and give bute, which puts him back to nearly normal. With bute for a few days, he’ll seem OK then for a few weeks, but happens again.

The horse has had several bouts of this type starting earlier this summer. He’s always been flat-footed and kept barefoot, so on vet recommendation we’ve added iron shoes with equipak cushioning to the front feet which immeidately seemed to make him more comfortable. Went 8 weeks between bouts, but now had another even with the shoes on.

Suggestions …thoughts?

Update 11/5/2016: Pedal Osteitis.

Have you done X-rays? Are you sure it isn’t laminitis?

That said I have a horse with a few degrees rotation in one hoof. His arthritis ha a caused me to have the vet out several times, worried he was having some sort of relapse of the laminitis because his arthritis was acting up.

thin soles?

That sounds a lot like laminitis. He is even a predisposed breed. Sometimes even though grass looks the same, a weather change (rain, dry spell, cold weather) can make the sugar levels skyrocket. Or, it could even be a weed, leaf, or tree he is eating. I recently went through laminitis that was induced by something they were eating (not grass) or stepping on.
For other options, It could be abscesses, navicular, a bad trim, stone bruises, a nail in the wrong part of the foot, arthritis, or an imbalance. I would strongly recommend getting a full blood panel done when he has one of his flare ups. (Check kidneys, RBC count, etc. everything, not just sugar levels) I would even get vitamin/minerals hair testing done, just to check for deficiencies.

How do his hooves look? Are their any ‘rings’ around the hooves, like ridge marks down the outside? How do his laminae look?

Has he been tested for Cushing’s disease? He’s a little young for it, but horses as young as seven can get it. It can cause chronic laminitis. Additionally, not all horses with it have some of the more classic symptoms (such as long, wavy fur).

Sorry don’t have a ton of time to write at the moment, will do more tomorrow. Briefly
-No recent Xrays yet, was planning to have a set done after he has had 3 shoeings (on round 2 now, so a few more weeks)
-Thin soles were the diagnosis by the vet (in June) and are why we put shoes with cushioning on
-I am not sure it’s not laminitis, mostly saying the typical trigger for it doesn’t seem to be present
-Has been tested for insulin resistance, and was good
-Abscesses have been an issue in the past, but nothing obvious these past four months
-Navicular hasn’t been discussed yet, but Xrays are in his future
-Hoof balance is good, according to two farriers and two vets
-Have had multiple blood panels taken in the past, but not right after\during a flareup
-Kidneys were tested and ultrasounded, no issues
-Hair testing for minerals\vitamins has not been done yet, on my to-do list
-Hooves have always been flat, very difficult to get any “concavity”
-Hooves have not shown rings in the past, but I do know to look for it
-Has been tested for Cushing’s twice, once with the ACTH test, and once with the Dex test, both negative

Keep the questions and suggestions coming … thank you! For now the horse is being retired from riding to give him at least the winter off. Also changed his boarding situation, so he’s got less room to move, fewer horses to contend with in pasture, and can be monitored more closely for these kinds of bouts.

Next time you change shoes ask the carriers opinion of the laminae. That can be a great indicator of laminitis episodes. ask if they are shallow, stressed, or bloody. If they are healthy, I would be doubtful of laminitis. It’s always possible, but usually laminitis shows symptoms in the laminae.

Forgot to ask, have you checked for injury in his withers, shoulders, or elbow joints? The rocking back could be reliving pressure/pain higher up.

[QUOTE=StormyDay;8903018]
Next time you change shoes ask the carriers opinion of the laminae. That can be a great indicator of laminitis episodes. ask if they are shallow, stressed, or bloody. If they are healthy, I would be doubtful of laminitis. It’s always possible, but usually laminitis shows symptoms in the laminae.[/QUOTE]

And in the separation on the white line.

I would think that maybe light tying up could be part of that, but with so many vets looking at him, that would be hard to miss with blood work and generally doesn’t affect hooves, or causes abscesses.

Has this horse had x-rays since the first episode? If so, what did they show?

[QUOTE=ladymcts;8903004]

-I am not sure it’s not laminitis, mostly saying the typical trigger for it doesn’t seem to be present[/QUOTE]
Less important are triggers, more important are symptoms/

If the blood is taken too soon, or too late after a tying up episode, the markers can be normal and “lie” about the issue.

I think we don’t know that this is (only) affecting the feet. Maybe sore feet make for some sore muscles for a bit? Maybe sore muscles make for hobbling and make feet sore?

I’d say the history of not just one but multiple abscesses, and the rocking back, really do point to frequent laminitis.

ladymcts - has this coincided with any weather change?

What is his entire diet - what, and how much?

I’d definitely start keeping a journal and write everything down every day - how he moves and stands, high and low temp for the day, humidity, any rainfall, high winds, anything. Then of course write anything else out of the ordinary - new horse in, or one left, got his feet done, something stressed him and he ran in the field or twirled around his stall, anything out of any routine.

I’d also say it’s past time for xrays :slight_smile: I think it’s beneficial at this point to know how thin the soles are (because flat soles are very often thinner), and exactly how his bony column lines up. It’s possible he’s got a traveling bone chip or 2, maybe some navicular issues (which can cause intermittent lameness), some pedal osteitis from the flat soles, etc.

When you do the xrays, make SURE the vet understand the importance of marking the true apex of the frog (not just where the tip is, it needs to be where the frog actually meets the sole, and often that requires paring back the tip until you find it), as well as the coronet band. That’s the only way you’re going to be able to get really accurate measurements about any sinking, and the A/P balance of the foot.

When was the last ACTH test and do you remember the result?

It definitely could be laminitis; and Cushings would contribute. And if he’s on grass, it is a lot trickier than you would imagine. My Cushings pony goes lame from grass when it rains, dry spells, warm spells where he can get to the grass under snow in winter. It’s really quite amazing how sensitive he is (so we keep him off the grass all the time now, but last winter he had a laminitic flare in February!)

Most horses are not so metabolically challenged, but grass can be more temperamental than you’d think.

I’d probably treat as laminitis until you know it’s not; an ACTH test can’t hurt either.

Tying up. Has PSSM been ruled out?

That must be frustrating. It sounds like your next step should be a set of X-rays. I hope you can find out what’s wrong (hopefully something treatable).

Another vote for laminitis. If he’s on pasture, even poor looking pasture, it’s probably the change in the grass wrt season/temp etc that is causing the problems. I’d get him off all pasture pronto, and get xrays pronto to see if there has been any rotation yet.

Between his foot soreness, and white line separation, I’d be thinking laminitis. Some bloodwork is order along with some radiographs.

OK, before I go on to any other answers … I should admit that I just had one hoof Xrayed last week. It was one of his hind feet which I suspected had an injury from a long time ago. The vet was unable to find anything really serious, but did see mild pedal osteitis. Now that I’m having more time to read up on that, it sure seems to fit this horse’s story.

He’s had chronically thin soles, flat footed, and his environment has been one which allows him to run wherever the he wants with acres to roam, a fairly big herd, and him being herd boss. If laminitis and\or chronic bruising of the coffin bone from too little sole cushion (pedal osteitis) are both part of his story, then my decision to move him last week to a much smaller barn with smaller herd and smaller pastures, and give him the winter off while continuing shoing with cushion supports, may all help him.

I will definitely be getting Xrays of the front feet soon. I was planning to get thru 3 cycles of shoes, per vet recommendation, before doing another set. That should get us to about January or so. If he continues to have laminitic-like episodes while at this new smaller facility and with shoes & equipak cushinging in place, then I will have those X-rays done sooner rather than later.

Now, back to some answers …

Laminae - Stressed and stretched, some separation. Not bloody.

Injury of withers, shoulders - This was one of the most recent suggestions by his current vet. After this last bout, she suggested our next step might be to test him again for insulin resistence, and then possibly pursue the full body imaging necessary to diagnose something like kissing spine. This horse did have significantly atrophied shoulder when purchased in 2012. That was missed during pre-purchase exam, and attempts to contact the seller and breeder went unanswered. Four years later, I can still see some difference between the two shoulders, but you have to really look for it. So I’ve always suspected maybe he had a shoulder injury as a colt.

Tying up, Part I - Is it possible to have a tying up episode with no physical exertion involved? This last laminitic episode occurred more than six weeks after the last time he was ridden, and 8 days after being trailered for a 1 hour round trip and shod. At the time it happened, he was in a paddock with other horses where there isn’t enough room to get up a good canter. He’s also herd boss and no changes to herd lately, so it’s not likely that he was chased around or doing chasing around to the point of real exertion.

Tying up, Part II - He was tested very thoroughly in early 2015. The university vet school kept him for four days and some of the testing involved ptuting him on a hot walker and monitoring muscle enzymes before, during, and after exercise. However, that was now more than 18 months ago, his first laminitic-like episode was in June of 2016.

PSSM\EPSM - While drafts in general are predisposed, it’s very rare in Clydesdales. I was advised that based on this horse’s symptoms, genetics, and history, that it was not worth pursuing the muscle biopsy. See two paragraphs above where they did some testing that should have identified muscle-related problems.

Weather change - These episodes have not coincided with weather change, but I would say they have generally coincided with some form of stress. Until the very last one which is why I’m writing … I don’t know what the heck brought this one on. No stress, no riding, no walking on hard surfaces. Not even out to pasture where he might have been thundering around and bruising his soles.

Diet - Two quarts of safe choice with a concoction of supplements that include Vitamin E, Hoof Supplement, Red Cell, and in summer months an electrolyte. Access to round-bale hay 24/7.

Journal - I’ve been keeping one of the big stuff, not thought to include weatehr factors yet. Thanks for the suggestion.

ACTH - January 2015, baseline was 13.3pg/ML

Bloodwork - I’ve had oodles of bloodwork taken in the past. The two things I have usually heard were “markers for inflammation” and “anemic.” Red Cell has helped address the anemia, but I’m aware that it’s just kind of putting a bandaid on something without knowing the root cause. His lifestyle does not suggest ulcers, but battling worms has been an issue, with frequent positive egg counts in spite of frequent dewormings with a good rotation plan. The most recent bloodwork was done a month ago (along with the Dex suppression test for Cushings), and it was good. No concern about inflammation or anemia. So I thought we were doing well … but this is the first laminitic-like episode since that bloodwork was done and getting shoes.

sigh thanks everyone!

In summary -
-Have changed his environment drastically
-He will be getting lots of time off this winter
-Will get Xrays at the very LEAST after his third set of shoes, but sooner if he has another incident
-If another incident, will do bloodwork again and will consider testing for insulin resistence again

Ditto Palm Beach - I’d take him off grass and Xray immediately! Laminitis is no joke, and the sooner you catch it, the better. My pony’s been recovering for months. We lost a critical week thinking he was just abcess-y. Note: continuing to shoe if he is starting with laminitis will make it much worse. I’d Xray now.

He’s full Clydesdale with documented lineage?

I would definitely get him off Safechoice anything. IIRC even the Special Care is not low enough NSC for a potentially IR or otherwise sugar-sensitive horse.

When was the blood drawn, in relation to him exercising, to come to the conclusion he’s anemic? It amazes me that vets STILL take blood from a rested horse, pronounce him anemic, without understanding there are enough RBCs stored in the spleen as to make the most healthy horse “anemic” until exercised.

Horses don’t need all that added iron, and adding so much, on a regular basis, is looking more and more like a potential catalyst for IR issues.

I would just start treating him as IR. Feed him as such, exercise him as much as possible given whatever issues are going on at any given moment.

Most definitely never do the dex suppression test again, and it’s also amazing to me that any vet would currently recommend that. The ACTH test is all that’s needed for Cushing’s, without the risk of inducing laminitis.