[QUOTE=ToTheNines;5772289]
Excellent post sportnhorse. I love the breed, and I can understand the desire to breed magnificent spotted horses. But it is not fair to the horses to breed them without a market, and people want to buy for specific disciplines.
Sorry, but a loud high stepping appy is not going to win hunter classes. I cannot speak as well to the other disciplines, maybe the loud ones will do better in dressage or eventing. Breeders, if you are hoping to sell hunters, I agree with sportnhorse, that the TB blood gives them the look and movement they need.
I have three hunter type appies, all registered ApHC, that have the look and movement to perform as hunters AND the appy personality we all love. However, they all have quite a bit of TB.
My older one has a very Andelusian head (from his App heritage), which I adore the look of. Not a big head, but gives him a very wise look that judges seem to love (at least at open h/j shows where he does not have to suffer the stupidity of QH judges). He is an excellent mover, and wins over fancy warmbloods at open shows. He is definitely Appy, and no one would mistake him for either a TB or a QH, but he was bred for hunters.
Here he is on the flat at an ApHC show (the chestnut):
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UzRRdiIosw4
And over fences, unfortunately, with the inept stupid QH judges they use at ApHC show:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YU2nHas6lvA
I also think the ApHC is not doing the breed any great service, but I do love the TB blood in the Apps, and they do well in the ApHC hunter classes.[/QUOTE]
Sorry but I agree with the inept stupid QH judges. The bay had a better rider who was able to present the horse in a much superior way. The chestnut is pretty but had a round with some issues many of which could be fixed by getting the rider some equitation lessons. Don’t take that personally as I don’t know ANY of the horses or riders but for heaven’s sake heels DOWN, shoulders BACK, look in the direction of travel, etc. etc. Neither are what I’d consider a great hunter for open shows but for a stock horse show they are both pretty good. At least they are moving forward.
My old appy was all foundation blood (way back some unknown and a Knab even) and he wasn’t a raving beauty but he could move like a dream and was a great hunter and jumper both in App and open company. Course now he’d be WAY too forward moving for an open show. Last big hunter class I saw at an A show they were going so slow I thought I’d been dropped back into QH land!