Isn’t a wee bit early?
We haven’t even seen the running of the Remsen Stakes (G2) which is decent test of those horses unlikely to have been Breeders’ Cup JV runners.
Early names in the late fall of the year prior rarely produce more then just a single runner or two still active, healthy, and developed enough be a big contender in the Derby.
A flash back for illustration …
From January 2, 2007, The Saratogian newspaper published the very first top 10 list for this year’s Derby hopefuls:
- Nobiz Like Shobiz
- Street Sense
- Tiz Wonderful
- Circular Quay
- Great Hunter
- Scat Daddy
- Stormello
- Liquidity
- Belgravia
- Horse Greeley
Street Sense - like War Pass - was a Breeders’ Cup JV winner and with it comes enough loot and the all important G1 win on the resume to be automatically on anyone’s list. However, outside of ‘Nobiz’, none of the other names were terribly of note on the first Saturday in May and of course several weren’t even starters.
Sad to say but unlike in years past, horses who were impressive in say the Saratoga Specia seem to fail to be around for the Derby. This year’s winner was Kodiak Kowboy. He may already be questionable at the 1 1/4 mi distance, but has earned enough money to be guaranteed a slot in the Kentucky Derby.
His record in 2007 is already 7 starts 4-1-1
10/27/07 $2M Bessemer Trust Breeders’ Cup Juvenile: Grade 1: Finished 3rd
09/15/07 $250K Futurity S. Belmont Park: Grade 2: Finished 2nd
08/16/07 $150K Saratoga Special S.: Grade 2: won
07/07/07 $150K Bashford Manor S. Churchill Downs: Grade 3: won
06/17/07 $125K Victoria S. Woodbine: ungraded: won
05/26/07 $48K Maiden Special Weight Churchill Downs: ungraded: won
04/29/07 $60K Maiden Special Weight Woodbine: ungraded: Finished 4th
By all accounts he’s improving, has multiple graded stakes victories and solid in the money finishes, however historically it could be said he and War Pass (vis-a-vis the BC jinx) could be tossed out 