[QUOTE=miss_critic;3071611]
I still don’t understand how the AR Derby is not a grade 1 and winstar is not a grade 3.[/QUOTE]
That was the point of a lot of folks - fans, horsemen, and racing writers - when the Graded Stakes Committee failed to upgrade that race last fall.
One example: “Graded Stakes system seriously flawed” Dec 8, 2007
The graded stakes committee announced that the Santa Anita Derby, the Blue Grass Stakes, the Wood Memorial and the Florida Derby would all be Grade 1 races in 2008. These committee members also announced, apparently with straight faces, that the Arkansas Derby would remain as a Grade 2 race.
What? Are you kidding me?
Let’s break this down a little more.
The past five Arkansas Derby winners have a combined lifetime record of 74 starts with 40 wins; 54 percent of the time they won their races. Their lifetime earnings are $18,900,059. Collectively, they have won the following Grade 1 races – Kentucky Derby, Preakness, Belmont, Breeders’ Cup Classic, Jockey Club Gold Cup, Oaklawn Handicap, Woodward, Whitney, Breeders’ Cup Juvenile, Hopeful, Champagne and of course they all won the lowly Grade 2 Arkansas Derby.
I cannot agree that future $$ earned really means much as Smarty Jones’ “earnings” in my view will always be an exceptionally skewed joke. Still the fact the winners of that Derby having gone on to win a lot of other big G1s suggest that prep is producing solid runners.