Definitely. Most non-commercial breeders consider the advice of agents, but the person who owns the mare makes the decision so I tend to give credit to the breeder. Especially with an unknown quantity such as C.C. it’s an educated guess at best, on everyone’s part.
I don’t doubt that Taylor Made did their best to get him good mares, but outside of their operation and the syndicate of owners, there wasn’t much interest in him from the owners of really good mares, thus his shuttle to Chile and eventual sale to Japan.
I don’t know anything about the interest or knowledge that C.C’s.former connections had in TB breeding, however private non-commercial breeders are often very knowledgeable. While some will listen to the (first year) stallion promoter, I would hesitate to give breeding credit to the stallion owner/ promoter, unless they are advising owners that are clueless and/or uninterested in studying pedigrees and phenotype.
It’s a different situation with established stallions, where there is so much more information available to everyone involved and there are a few crops with racing form to study. JMHO.