My search continues, and I’m about to spend $100 returning blankets, argh.
Weatherbeetas were all wrong for my mare. Huge gaping necks. I tried two styles of Amigo XL 1200D, and they were much too tight in the shoulders. I had one I thought would work, but my mare could barely walk in it. Also, the Amigos were static magnets, and she nearly had a meltdown every time I removed one.
My BO let me try a size 72 Rhino Wug on my mare, and it was a little short but otherwise fit well. I’m normally not a huge fan of the Wugs as she can be high-headed at times (Morgan), but this was good enough that I’ve ordered a size 75.
She’s just a funny size. She is pretty low-slung (just under 15 hands, wears a size 75 or 76), has very prominent and long withers, and deep shoulders, but is very narrow-chested. Schneiders sort of worked but didn’t seem to hold their waterproofing well… This was about 12 years ago.