I’m also not a Weatherbeeta fan. I bought a brand new Comfitec Dynamic rain sheet and it wasn’t waterproof. The cheap Amigo Hero 600D that I picked up at a local tack shop as a stand in fit better and was more waterproof…for well under $100.
A friend’s QH who is massive in her shoulders, neck, and whole body is wearing a Schneider’s and it fits her full figure very well. I’ve had waterproofing issues with them in the past, and Idk how hers performs since I mostly only ride her/go there in nicer weather, coincidentally.
I haven’t tried the Centaur 150g on my yearling yet, I went off of a recommendation on here since he’s still narrow in front.
I had a Schneider’s 1200D and a Tough-1 1200D 200g next to each other recently and honestly, not a huge difference and the Tough-1 is far less money. I’m not convinced that the Schneider’s is really worth more, personally.