Hereâs NJ law on the subject, which sounds like Warmblood1âs post:
30:4-27.20. Discharge of voluntary patients
A voluntary patient at a short-term care or psychiatric facility or special psychiatric hospital shall be discharged by the treatment team at the patientâs request. The treatment team shall document all requests for discharge, whether oral or written, in the patientâs clinical record. The facility shall discharge the patient as soon as possible but in every case within 48 hours or at the end of the next working day from the time of the request, whichever is longer, except that if the treatment team determines that the patient needs involuntary commitment, the treatment team shall initiate court proceedings pursuant to section 10 of this act. The facility shall detain the patient beyond 48 hours or the end of the next working day from the time of the request for discharge, only if the court has issued a temporary court order.
I think you would be surprised. Also, I donât know if you mean to imply this, but many psychiatric conditions are treatable. Often what decides which are not responsive to treatment have more to do with comorbidities in the patient than the treated condition.
So one person with depression may not have the successful outcome that another with schizophrenia does.
LOL. Youâre right, every doctor is going to risk their medical license and the safety of the public or their patients by allowing a patient who has admitted they have intent to kill themselves or someone else to just walk out the door any time. No problems there.
And youâre right, every window and door is left wide open, unlocked. Because thatâs how facilities house patients that are a danger to themselves and/or others. Let them leave at their will to commit homicide.
/sarcasm
By the way, most patients in private facilities are voluntary. Iâd say 8/10. Once they are admitted, protocol is no different from voluntary versus involuntary. Does not matter.
Ok, but LK has so few âsupportersâ and fewer that seem to have managed to mention things that can only be attributed to CotH. Specifically ones that make references that seem to relate directly to you two.
This is a very important comment. It is my opinion that MOST mental health issues are treatable. It is to Barisoneâs benefit that he sought medical help years ago and had learned skills to help him with life.
I hope Dr. Simring has been able to communicate with Michael professionally and has coordinated with the medical staff at AK, if appropriate.
I think of all the men I know who returned from Vietnam with severe PTSD. Of those who sought help all became successful, happy individuals. Those who ignored help seemed to flounder in their private lives, my brother included, and were never quite whole again.
You do realize that involuntary patients and voluntary patients are housed in the same ward, yes?
A patient is not committed on the sole basis they have depression. They have to show imminent danger to themselves or someone else, or be significantly unable to care for themselves to an extent that they present imminent danger to themselves or others.
Also, whether the psychiatric conditions are âtreatableâ has no bearing on threat or risk. That is not how commitment is determined.
ETA: regarding treatment, every psychiatric condition is âtreatable.â Not every psychiatric condition is curable. There arenât any psychiatric conditions where their doctor would say, do not apply any treatment, there is no potential for response. Any psychiatric condition has the potential to respond to treatment.
It is also an assessment site, where people go to be assessed regarding their current mental status and the safety of the person being assessed and the larger communityâs safety if they were to be released now. In other words, you donât have to be committed in order to be there. You could be there for an assessment prior to release.
I think Barisone will be home in time for Christmas, figuring in delays in the court system.
Sheilah
Not true. They are in a locked unit just like the involuntarily committed patients. Difference is they can discharge themselves. That is the ONLY difference.
Sheilah
Hereâs the deal. LK is losing (lost) in the court of public opinion. LK doesnât know how to lose. Daddy O has never allowed that. She doesnât know how to handle the big L. She will continue to get the big L as long as she stomps her feet and screams at her windshield. Well adjusted people have introspect and grow. Thatâs not the case here and thatâs why so many people are astounded by her actions.
Hear, hear. Horses usually humble most and the ones that are humbled are usually excellent horse people. There seems to be a small group of people attracted to riding who are all about control, however. Trying to control all aspects of their life and I feel controlling horses can fuel that need.
I did not see any competition results under her name on the USEF site before the first dressage results a few years back. Obviously, that would not exclude the possibility of unrecognized hunter/jumper shows.