And “managing intact dogs” is not always simply a matter of training and being careful, especially in a multi-dog household. I am a long time dog owner, a long time intact dog own since I show conformation (I don’t breed), and the stress on the other animals when a bitch is in season in the household should not be under played.
It bothers EVERYONE, not just the males, not just the bitch in question. The males often stop eating, everyone’s tempers are on edge, my older spayed female gets stomach issues and starts puking up her meals … most pet owners don’t have the network to send a pup to visit grandma for two weeks every six months or more.
I ended up spaying my latest female not because I was worried about her health but because she becomes a raging bitch when in season, starting fights with everyone if she could get to them. Once I finished her grand championship, the stress and WORK of keeping her and everyone else safe was not worth being able to continue showing her.
To downplay spay and neutering as a mere “convenience” is doing everyone, including the animals, a disservice.