I donāt believe anyone here thinks that horses arenāt better off with turn-out, or that most horses prefer their stalls to turn-out OR that anyone here is saying Totilas is āso nuttyā he canāt be turned out. (Did I miss that?)
Itās the decision of the owners/managers of the individual horse, though, and none of our business. And thatās the gist of my argument. Perhaps the owners/managers of certain horses are more risk-averse than others. What can you do? Itās not your horse.
Hand walking is better than nothing. At least the horse gets out for a nice stroll, spends time with its handler, gets to see the sights. At weekend horse shows, thatās all our horses get, in between classes.
Hand grazing is better than nothing, and when our grass-growing season is over, or in drought conditions, hand grazing is about as good as it gets for some horses in Colorado (for instance).
I will say that, on very cold days, or very ābuggyā summer days, the horses where I board are often quite eager to get back to their cozy stalls. Naturally, by the next morning, they are just as eager to go out again, evidently forgetting that only yesterday they were miserable.
I think the ideal situation is one where horses can come and go from their shelters as they please. That doesnāt suit everyone, though.