The increment system DOES need an overhaul - but not, perhaps, in ways people are thinking…
I really like the system of points for clear rounds (Jumpers in Ireland til they get to a certain level) AND points per horses beat - NO EXTRA points for Champion or Reserve (you already HAVE more points). Perhaps some SCALE of points indicating the QUALITY of show (but, that, by definition is another, uh hornets’ nest
) The AHQA uses the 1 pt per 5 horses beat (1/2 for 3) and it allows them to make award on the LONG TERM (lifetime of the horse) as well as the short term (annually). This, to me, makes sense - AND it would also give people some perspective on the divisions - for example, that horse that won Reserve at XXX show, may have only been competing agains 3 horses and probably won the hack! So while these horses may get mega AHSA points for this “win”/competition, in actuality, they didn’t do much - and by AQHA standards would have gotten 1/2 point and ONLY in the classes they won…
Lifetime achievement award for a horse (and especially for amateurs - who don’t get to show much) give people who haven’t a chance of winning national or zone awards, a GOAL…
Of course, the other change that these 70 pages point to is a change of the way hunters are judged. What happened to DIFFERENT priorities for different divisions?? I happen to LIKE the idea of a “dressage-like” score sheet - not that it has to LIMIT the course builders, but that it gives the judges an opportunity to numerically differentiate between JUMPING, between fences, manners, suitability, brilliance, etc. It would take a LOT of work to develop these, but I think worth the effort.
I have proposed the two above ideas several times over the past three or four years, and, essentially, except here on the BB, they have been ignored.
There is no doubt, something has to be done - AND if we can approach the problem from BOTH sides - increased fines and drug testing as well as changes in the SYSTEM, we might make a step further toward saving our horses.
It’s OUT! Linda Allen’s 101 Exercises for Jumping co-authored by MOI!!!