The latest and greatest one I heard was watching a lesson the other day at the barn where I lease a horse. The coach was supposedly helping the girl work on bending her horse (as much as you can with an unengaged horse and minimal attempts to engage it) . The exercise looked like this
Walk down the quarter line, turn horse’s neck completely sideways (think no outside aids) and then kick her in the side to get her to turn around
Trainer exclaims “GOOD!”
Walk back to trainer
Begin turn on forehand. Hindquarters move two steps. Front quarters move two steps. This continues. Trainer once again praises, albeit this time lightly, but never mentions that the front quarters are supposed to stay in place.
Rider goes large and trots around once. Goes back to walk. Proceeds to walk up to trainer across the diagnol.
Trainer: “No, no, you can’t get them to bend while they are on the diagonal!”
Huh? Now, I know you can keep them straight coming across the diagonal, but you can also bend them, and change their bend, etc. I also know the horse very well, and the horse already knows how to do everything they ask (engage, bend, turn on the forehand, etc) so it’s not a matter of slowly introducing the horse to the concept (or the rider).
I turn to my friend “Did I just hear what I thought I heard?”
My friend “Unforetunately.”
This is a few weeks after watching them school the horse over fences. The line was a three stride and the jumps were about 2’. The horse jumps in calm as can be and the rider slams on the brakes. Horse flings it’s head in the air and piles on the brakes immediately (good horse) within the last stride before the second element. Apparently they are teaching this poor soul not to rush. Eek.