I took a peak at that one a few days ago, but held off from commenting when all the whatcha-bout arguements started. Seems like a lot of people are really upset by something relatively simple.
2 Likes
… that has no research backing it. That’s my issue. If this was an honest to god horse welfare issue, none of us would do it. But realistically, it’s not a horse welfare issue. It’s a feel-good maneuver to take the heat off the important stuff such as:
It’s legal to do this to your horse in warmup:
And Marilyn Little can do this and that’s ok:
And flash bands can be this tight and that’s fine:
2 Likes
i haven’t been on for awhile as my laptop gave it up! Had to ask for a new password. But anyway…is it ok, that the IRONY of this thread to share ones that went sideways to now have this one do the same thing? 2020 JUST HAS TO END.
11 Likes
The irony is not lost on me.
3 Likes
I can understand people not being happy with it! There are always people upset with any change to the status-quo (good or bad). I’ve watched threads go off the rails over all sorts of non-important details that had nothing to do with welfare or training methods, let alone ones actually about welfare or training methods. My two favorites were people getting upset about the color piping allowed on jackets during hunter classes and the ugliness of non-braided hair for showing.
O man I saw the eventing one and… OOF. A lot of bad takes in there.
1 Like
A post was merged into an existing topic: Eventing Nation booted from covering Event in Unionville, PA
So now the “Most Bizarre gone wrong thread” about train wrecks has turned into a train wreck. The irony is so thick around here. 
13 Likes
truth, makes me sad. wish they would have begun their own, and then joined the top 10 here. was meant to share specific threads that fit that criterion…not infuse one within it. 
This one went weird, with the OP deleting posts, but they had been quoted for the most part. The end was really bizarre. Would anyone?
1 Like
Are you serious? 
I’m sorry, but honestly yes! my laptop died and I haven’t been back on this thread for ages…but I began it…so am I the OP you meant?
I believe they meant the OP of the thread they linked in that comment!
ok, didn’t see a thread link…operating on an old tablet until new laptop is received and charged/set up.
The OP of the thread “Would Anyone” that I linked to in my post. Nothing to do with you. Sorry my post was unclear.
no…I"m sorry! I just didn’t realize the link. mea culpa
THAT was great, thanks! I needed something to cheer me up while I’m sitting here sick.
For a bit, though, that thread reminded me of a girl I knew when I was a working student. She did 3rd level, thought she was The Bomb, and finally our instructor had enough of the attitude and had a friend bring her Grand Prix horse over one day for a clinic. Miss Third Level never did figure out how to get the horse to stop piaffing. Man, I wish I had that on video . . .
My sincere apologies to all for being the first to mention that thread.
There are forums that have a rule that an argument cannot be dragged to another thread. Hopefully COTH is one of them.
1 Like
Honesty, I found it slightly sad that a young person would feel it so difficult to tell the truth and would go to such lengths to lie. That, I believe, is the downside of allowing young teenagers on BBs that are comprised mainly of adults.
There are many ways of being young and stupid.We oldies did it on horses, as we were not of the internet age.
Hopefully this young person learned from the experience and is well and happy today. 
1 Like
We removed a tangent getting more into personal commentary between a couple of posters and continuing discussion from another thread. If anyone would like their posts moved over to the whisker thread, we’re happy to do that, but it sounds like the points were already being made on that thread.
7 Likes
